Page 1 of 1

Filter Material

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:56 pm
by Dadof4
Anyone hear anything good or bad about Biobale filter media? Looking to change over to it because of cost vs bio balls.

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 2:49 am
by Pufferpunk
What application are you using it for? I don't like bioballs for SW. It came with both of my Backpac skimmer, clogged quickly, which makes them nitrate factories, like any other mechanical filtration does in SW.

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 1:05 pm
by Dadof4
This is going to be for a second wet/dry filter on my 180. I have bio balls in my first one and but I feel the need to add a second one and I was thinking bio bale would be a cheaper option. I've seen it used in some mass produced wet/dry's so I'm curious. If I hear bad response I am going to spend a wad of cash on ceramic/porous glass media. It's like $30 vs $120.

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 2:55 pm
by Pufferpunk
You still didn't say if this is for SW. If it is--IMO, wet/dry is a filtration of the past & is a nitrate factory.

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 3:33 pm
by Dadof4
Oh, duh, I was just waking up when I answered that.....This is for a FW 180 gallon. What I have set up now is one DIY wet/dry with a pre-filter sponge both on the overflow (darn non pre drilled tanks) and on the Wet/dry itself to catch the lager particles. I clean my pre filters with every water change, a weekly habit I've gotten in to, so there is no excessive build up of organic material.

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 3:40 pm
by Pufferpunk
Well, I've never had bioballs but found the "noodles" to be easy to rinse off. Still a PITA in my skimmer though, as they'd clog up. Almost had one overflow right before vacation--good thing I looked at it before I left!

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 5:20 pm
by flash.dan
best bet is DIY FBF get it just right and youll have nio issues with filtration

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 8:09 pm
by Dadof4
I had thoughts of buying a FBF http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/p ... catid=3654 in addition to the wet/dry for kicks and water flow in the tank. I'm too lazy/busy to make one. Do you think that FBF plus a circulating pump with a manifold return setup in the tank for water movement would be enough?

So here's what I have planned for filtration:
1) 2 wet/dry filters made from 5 gallon buckets being fed by a CPR 1200gph overflow.
2) The above sitting in a 55 gallon tank.
3) The above listed FBF hanging on the side of the 55 gal tank (it can be set up that way) for oxygenation from the waterfall effect back in to the 55 gallon.
4) Return pump with 1600gph flow at 6' head height and an inline flow control valve.
5) DIY return manifold in the 180 to create river flow effect.
5) One happy Fahahka....to be seen.

Should I eliminate the wet/dry and just do a loop from the overflow to a 55 gallon tank with the FBF hang on side and the planned return system?

Re: Filter Material

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 3:46 am
by flash.dan
Dadof4 wrote:I had thoughts of buying a FBF http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/p ... catid=3654 in addition to the wet/dry for kicks and water flow in the tank. I'm too lazy/busy to make one. Do you think that FBF plus a circulating pump with a manifold return setup in the tank for water movement would be enough?

So here's what I have planned for filtration:
1) 2 wet/dry filters made from 5 gallon buckets being fed by a CPR 1200gph overflow.
2) The above sitting in a 55 gallon tank.
3) The above listed FBF hanging on the side of the 55 gal tank (it can be set up that way) for oxygenation from the waterfall effect back in to the 55 gallon.
4) Return pump with 1600gph flow at 6' head height and an inline flow control valve.
5) DIY return manifold in the 180 to create river flow effect.
5) One happy Fahahka....to be seen.

Should I eliminate the wet/dry and just do a loop from the overflow to a 55 gallon tank with the FBF hang on side and the planned return system?


I had a 4 foot FBF up until last week as im selling up that was 4 foot and held 8kilos of silca sand it was rated up to 35,000 L and i never had any issues at all. i think your nile will love you forever if you tie it in with a wet dry also