Page 1 of 2

Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 11:15 am
by pavnatalia
Hello:

We used to have a porcupine puffer fish and a cow fish up until yesterday.. The puffer was with us for about 4 months and a month ago we got the cow fish. Two weeks ago the cow fish got ich, transfered it to the puffer and then died yesterday.. killing everyone in the tank, including the puffer, Stewie.

Now we are starting over, and this time we want to do it right. We got a UV Sterilizer, the twist one. We already have a good skimmer, a lot of live rock, and now need help with a new filter and heater. We do have those as well, of course, but they are old and we need to replace them before we put new fish in (in about 1-2 months).

Please suggest a good filter system and a heater for a reasonable price for a 55 gallon salt water tank and explain why it is good. Also, what else should we consider buying so that the fish are healthy and happy?

Thank you for all your advice!

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 2:01 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I'm very sorry for the loss of your puffer and cow fish, but I'm curious -- did you not try to do anything about the ich that they had gotten? I mean, it is something you can do something about, and you needn't have lost both of your fish.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 2:39 pm
by pavnatalia
Yes, we did treat both of them following our lfs advice. We also did fresh water dips daily, but it did not help. The problem was that we did not quarantine the cow fish before we put her in the puffer's tank.. that killed them. Now we want to desinfect the water and of course to quarantine the new fish that we get.

Can you help us with the filter and heater? What brands should we consider for a 55 gallon tank?

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 2:56 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I've just recently got a new filter for my 56-gallon tank, an Eheim. It's fantastic. If you can afford one, then I'd go with that. They are very quiet and do a great job, but they can be a bit pricey. I can't really suggest one heater more than another, just make sure you get at least a 300-watt for a tank your size.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 3:25 pm
by pavnatalia
Thank you! Do you think this one could work? http://www.amazon.com/Eheim-Canister-Fi ... 976&sr=8-1

As for heaters, which one do you have? Can you suggest where to look?

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 3:37 pm
by Pufferpunk
[welcome]

You do not need a filter for a SW tank. A GOOD skimmer & live rock/sand is it. Please look into the adult size of your fish & the minimum tank size recomendations. You'll need at LEAST a 100g just for an 12-18" Porc. Most cowfish species grow to 18''.

All a FW dip does is remove the cysts off the fish. Then you put it back into infected water. Please read the article on treating SW "ich" in our Library. I suggest doing a ton more research on keeping SW fish & tanks, before getting more fish.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 3:39 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Yes, that's a good filter that you're looking at. Do you have an eBay account at all? That's where I buy all my aquarium accessories, you can usually get better prices off there. As for a heater, I'd go with any brand you can find at a decent price, just go for a 300-watt heater.
I would also suggest buying an inexpensive internal filter, as I try to have more than one filter on all my tanks and I've got 3 on my 56-gallon tank (my Eheim external, an Interpet internal and a hang-on filter). Can't hurt to have more filtration than what you think is necessary, and not only that, but if you choose to start a new tank in the future, you can always take one of those filters from that tank and it's already cycled!
Good luck! :D

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 3:49 pm
by Pufferpunk
Again--I highly suggest against using FW filters for SW tanks, they are nitrate factories. Live rock/sand & a good protein skimmer is all you need.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 3:51 pm
by pufferpuggirl
To be honest, I forgot we were talking about a saltwater tank, and I have no experience with those at all. So I was probably thinking about a freshwater or brackish tank. My mistake. :?

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:03 pm
by pavnatalia
<b>schismy007 </b>
Oh, okay :) That's fine.

<b>Pufferpunk </b>
I think we would like to get a filter. Just in case. Is there one you can recommend that does its job and is not harmful ? What about a heater?

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:08 pm
by Pufferpunk
You're not listening. I really think you need to do a lot more research in keeping SW systems & how they work.

I've always been happy with Jager heaters.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:16 pm
by pavnatalia
Thank you for your responses. Currently we have both a skimmer and a filter (I don't know the brands as my husband got them). I notice that when we clean the filter (once every one-two months) and change the filter pads (every two weeks) there's a lot of waste. It's hard to believe that the skimmer alone will do the job that before both of them were doing..

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:25 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Your filter is catching the waste before the skimmer can get it. If you took out the filter, you'd see the skimmer getting all of that waste.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:35 pm
by Pufferpunk
+1, you're still thinking in FW filtration mode, not SW. Forget everything you know about FW filtration.

Re: Help to Choose a Good Filter and Heater

Posted: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:55 pm
by pavnatalia
LilGreenPuffer and Pufferpunk
Thank you so much for all your help. I think that with the UV Sterilizer and quarantining our new fish, we will have success. We will not get a new filter and put away the old one. Is there anything else we should consider for the tank?