Page 1 of 1
new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Fri Aug 14, 2009 9:40 pm
by midnight_iggy
Hello,
My fiance and i have been looking into getting a GSP for a few months now. We have read a lot of literature on the subject and the only thing that we are still worried about was the GSP breaking our tank over time. We spoke to a guy in the fish section at our local petco ( i know, not the best info source

) and he was telling us a horror story of a friend of his who supposedly had 4 GSP at 8inches long that would chew on the glass and finally broke the tank.
The employee didnt seem to know anything about snails, which we had read kept this problem in check, and was the whole reason we were at the pet store. So i guess we would like to know how often these lovely guys really break tanks, how to prevent it for sure, and are snails the only way to go? We have gone to every pet store in town and no one sells small snails anymore. Can we use scallops? Clams?
Any info would be great. To give a bit of info our tank setup would be a 55gallon, for the GSP only. We were thinking about getting about 3 of the same size (the store around here sells them at about 2 inches). We are aware of how to keep brackish water, what they eat, size, and lifespan. We thought we were also ready on the snail subject until this came up but I'm hoping you can help us with that.
Thank you in advance
edited to say we were just talking that the local grocery sells muscles in the shell, would this work as a substitute for snails since we cannt find any in town?
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 12:58 am
by Dadof4
I've heard that as rumor and it's always, "My friend had a friend that had a puffer in a tank that...." with many different endings. Everything is anecdotal with no hard proof. I have heard of them rubbing their teeth on acrylic tanks and leaving marks though. My GSP rubs his teeth on the glass tank and there is no problem. Anyone else hear of them breaking a tank?
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 4:21 am
by bigfatfish
No! Not heard of one reach 8" long either! Wonder if its one of those old wives tales that has got a little more exagerated over time!
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 4:57 am
by LilGreenPuffer
You will only be able to keep two GSPs in a 55.
Also, just checking - you know that to make brackish water, you have to use a salt mix intended for saltwater aquariums, right? Many people use "aquarium salt," which is actually a medicine. You'll need a hydrometer or refractometer to measure salinity, too. Just checking - most people who are new don't know that.

Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 10:29 am
by Dadof4
midnight_iggy wrote: edited to say we were just talking that the local grocery sells muscles in the shell, would this work as a substitute for snails since we cannt find any in town?
These would be fantastic, mussel is kind of a universal favorite amongst the wet, slimy, puffer crowd these days.
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 2:00 pm
by pufferpuggirl
The puffer breaking the tank sounds like one of those urban legends/myths to me! I've never heard of that happening for real, however, I have heard of puffers scratching those plastic tanks, but not breaking them.
I would think if you can't get snails, any type of food that has a shell that the puffers would have to chew or break open would serve the same purpose. However, back to the snails ... do you know anyone that has an outdoor natural pond? You can easily get pond snails there and most pond owners would be happy to let you have them as they eat aquatic plants. Just thought I'd mention it in case you did know someone with a pond who may be able to help you.
And just another note: I never measure my brackish water, never have and never will. I believe that brackish water should not be exact, of course I do stick to a basic "recipe". If we were talking about a marine tank then I'd definitely say that a hydrometer would be much needed. But that's just me.

Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 6:05 pm
by midnight_iggy
schismy007 wrote:
And just another note: I never measure my brackish water, never have and never will. I believe that brackish water should not be exact, of course I do stick to a basic "recipe". If we were talking about a marine tank then I'd definitely say that a hydrometer would be much needed. But that's just me.

Awesome, we thought it might be a myth but always better to check
And we thought we might have to get another 30+ gallon tank as they get bigger for one anyways, so thats no big issue =)
As for the brackish water, we have seen the basic ways to do it online but we havent seen any true "recipes" is there a link to that anywhere that i could find?
Again, awesome info for the muscles to. We dont know anyone with a pond that i can think of but ill keep it in mind.

We have read that some people smash the muscles up before giving them and some just plop them in whole, which would be better for a around 2inch puffer? Any amount a good rule for feeding? One muscle per puffer or just throw a few in and get rid of what they dont want?
Again thanks for the info, there is a lot of great info online but some contradicts itself so much that it can get overwhelming at times

Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 9:30 pm
by Dadof4
What I do with Mussels is open the shell, scrape most of the meat off the shell, and freeze it on a plate. The shell I freeze too and later I defrost it drop the half shell in. They pick the meat off it and scrape their teeth on the shell in the process.
As for the hydrometer, I feel it's essential to measure your water as you raise or lower the SG in your tank because you can only raise or lower by .002 per week without killing any nitrifying bacteria. Schismy007 not measuring the SG of her tanks is fine for her at this point because she has them established at the SG she wants and she knows how much salt to add to how much water to get close to the current SG. In nature Brackish water does vary in SG quite a bit, sometimes hour by hour, and her not being exact makes things more natural for her fish. There is also a massive biologic filtration system in play in nature. In an aquarium the biologic filter is only what we provide and it is small and any die off of nitrifying bacteria can cause a tank crash. I have one of my brackish tanks established at the SG it should be and, honestly, I don't check the SG of the water I use to do water changes either every time I mix it. I do check every time I get a new bucket of salt though or I want to make a raise in SG.
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 11:52 pm
by mrgreen
Dadof4 wrote:What I do with Mussels is open the shell, scrape most of the meat off the shell, and freeze it on a plate. The shell I freeze too and later I defrost it drop the half shell in. They pick the meat off it and scrape their teeth on the shell in the process.
I have just started feeding mussels. I usually thaw in tank water, then pry the shell open and put in the tank. I know he's not scraping his teeth this way. Its late. I'll re-read your method in the morning. I'm a little confused about what you're doing. I do need to figure it out, though, because my new F8 is a little long in the tooth. Not hugely so, but he just needs some crunchy foods. He started with a shell-on raw prawn and ate the legs and took a chunk out of the tail, so we're off to a good start. I think he was in bliss with all that food!
Re: new GSP owner, beak question
Posted: Sun Aug 16, 2009 5:49 am
by pufferpuggirl
I use a basic recipe for my mudskippers, which are brackish, and that's 2 Tablespoons of marine salt for each 4 and a half liters of water, which I believe is one US gallon (+ or -).
Once I got my salinity up in my puffer's tank (done slowly as to not kill my filter), I just started adding to that recipe, and now I'm up to adding three 2-tablespoons measurements (I have a spoon that is exactly 2 Tbsp). Sometimes when I mix the water up, I put a little more in, and sometimes a little less, but I do stick to a "basic" amount, so it's not like I'm varying it THAT much. It's been working for me and I have 4 brackish tanks, so far, so good.
