Page 1 of 1
different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 1:04 pm
by rachy
i have 2 puffer tanks, a 35l with 3 dwarf puffers, and a 240 with 2 saps and 8 black neon tetras. would it b ok to move the dwarfs into the big tank with the others?? its quite heavily planted, a lot of hiding places etc. just thinking the dwarfs might b happier in a bigger tank?
Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 1:17 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.
By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.
Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:23 pm
by rachy
LilGreenPuffer wrote:The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.
By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.
cheers for the reply

the dwarfs do seem happy in the small tank yep, just thought maybe it would b better for them 2 b in bigger

but if its better 2 leave them then thats cool!! n as for having more sap's, i am on the lookout for some lol!! would like another 2 or 3. but since i got shaun + paddy, ive never been able 2 find anymore tho

hopefully some will turn up before long!
Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:26 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Keep an eye on the classifieds here, and your LFS might be able to order some, too.
Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:33 pm
by pufferpuggirl
rachy wrote:LilGreenPuffer wrote:The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.
By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.
cheers for the reply

the dwarfs do seem happy in the small tank yep, just thought maybe it would b better for them 2 b in bigger

but if its better 2 leave them then thats cool!! n as for having more sap's, i am on the lookout for some lol!! would like another 2 or 3. but since i got shaun + paddy, ive never been able 2 find anymore tho

hopefully some will turn up before long!
Just wanted to say that I've had Dwarf Puffers living with SAP's for about a year and have never had any problems at all. In fact, they've all been very happy together. I think, personally, that you can get away with it, especially as you say your tank is very heavily planted, which will make a difference.
It's too bad Rachy that you didn't let me know before you wanted some SAP's. I've had 3 for sale for several weeks now. I think someone may be coming for them soon though. What part of the UK are you in?
Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:38 pm
by rachy
schismy007 wrote:
Just wanted to say that I've had Dwarf Puffers living with SAP's for about a year and have never had any problems at all. In fact, they've all been very happy together. I think, personally, that you can get away with it, especially as you say your tank is very heavily planted, which will make a difference.
It's too bad Rachy that you didn't let me know before you wanted some SAP's. I've had 3 for sale for several weeks now. I think someone may be coming for them soon though. What part of the UK are you in?
now im not sure what 2 do lol

would defo prefer them all in the big tank, so they have more space etc. and im in county durham, near a place called bishop auckland

Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:53 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Well I'm being honest with you, I've never had any problems with my Dwarf puffers living with other puffers. In fact, I had the DP's together with the SAP's and a few Figure 8 puffers in the same tank.
Now I've moved the SAP's over to my community tank and I still have some DP's in there and they don't bother anyone at all. Okay, I've seen them nip the corydoras once or twice, but it was more like a "move on you're in my space" type nip, not harassment.
I'm in Worksop, in Notts.

Re: different puffers living together
Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 6:13 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
You could always give it a try and then change back if it doesn't work. Keep the DP tank cycled by feeding it ammonia or fish food, and you could move them back with no problem.