Page 1 of 1

different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 1:04 pm
by rachy
i have 2 puffer tanks, a 35l with 3 dwarf puffers, and a 240 with 2 saps and 8 black neon tetras. would it b ok to move the dwarfs into the big tank with the others?? its quite heavily planted, a lot of hiding places etc. just thinking the dwarfs might b happier in a bigger tank?

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 1:17 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.

By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:23 pm
by rachy
LilGreenPuffer wrote:The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.

By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.
cheers for the reply :) the dwarfs do seem happy in the small tank yep, just thought maybe it would b better for them 2 b in bigger :) but if its better 2 leave them then thats cool!! n as for having more sap's, i am on the lookout for some lol!! would like another 2 or 3. but since i got shaun + paddy, ive never been able 2 find anymore tho :( hopefully some will turn up before long!

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:26 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Keep an eye on the classifieds here, and your LFS might be able to order some, too.

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:33 pm
by pufferpuggirl
rachy wrote:
LilGreenPuffer wrote:The DPs are probably pretty happy in the 35l, actually. Thing is, the SAPs will probably get picked on. No, really - they are very passive, and DPs are very aggressive.

By the way, you may want to consider another SAP or two. I think you've got the space (I'm not so great with liters to gallons), and they really prefer to live in groups of at least three.
cheers for the reply :) the dwarfs do seem happy in the small tank yep, just thought maybe it would b better for them 2 b in bigger :) but if its better 2 leave them then thats cool!! n as for having more sap's, i am on the lookout for some lol!! would like another 2 or 3. but since i got shaun + paddy, ive never been able 2 find anymore tho :( hopefully some will turn up before long!

Just wanted to say that I've had Dwarf Puffers living with SAP's for about a year and have never had any problems at all. In fact, they've all been very happy together. I think, personally, that you can get away with it, especially as you say your tank is very heavily planted, which will make a difference.

It's too bad Rachy that you didn't let me know before you wanted some SAP's. I've had 3 for sale for several weeks now. I think someone may be coming for them soon though. What part of the UK are you in?

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:38 pm
by rachy
schismy007 wrote: Just wanted to say that I've had Dwarf Puffers living with SAP's for about a year and have never had any problems at all. In fact, they've all been very happy together. I think, personally, that you can get away with it, especially as you say your tank is very heavily planted, which will make a difference.

It's too bad Rachy that you didn't let me know before you wanted some SAP's. I've had 3 for sale for several weeks now. I think someone may be coming for them soon though. What part of the UK are you in?

now im not sure what 2 do lol :D would defo prefer them all in the big tank, so they have more space etc. and im in county durham, near a place called bishop auckland :)

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:53 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Well I'm being honest with you, I've never had any problems with my Dwarf puffers living with other puffers. In fact, I had the DP's together with the SAP's and a few Figure 8 puffers in the same tank.

Now I've moved the SAP's over to my community tank and I still have some DP's in there and they don't bother anyone at all. Okay, I've seen them nip the corydoras once or twice, but it was more like a "move on you're in my space" type nip, not harassment.

I'm in Worksop, in Notts. :D

Re: different puffers living together

Posted: Wed Aug 12, 2009 6:13 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
You could always give it a try and then change back if it doesn't work. Keep the DP tank cycled by feeding it ammonia or fish food, and you could move them back with no problem.