Page 1 of 1

Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 9:56 pm
by mrgreen
I've had my new 5.5 gallon tank for 3 weeks. I know its still cycling. My lfs said to cycle with fish so I had 4 danios and 2 tetras. I've been doing w/c about twice a week at about 80 %. I did put some fresh oyster in several days ago and left it in longer than I should have, probably. (The danios and tetras took to it with relish.) I did a big water change after I removed it, then did a water test. The readings were normal except nitrates which were huge- as in about 5! Dark purple. Wait- that reading was before the w/c. Its only been a couple days and I decided to return the fish and see about getting the neon tetras and possibly a hatchet or two. I brought a water sample and again it was extremely high in nitrates! They said "Your tank is finishing its cycle." I said "Why is it that high? I did a big water change." She said "You shouldn't do water changes. You're starting the cycle over new when you do that." Every thing I've read- here and other places- says "Water changes water changes water changes!" I have put in Safe start a few times. I've put in some media from my other (cycled healthy) tank. Should I continue the water changes until I get a zero reading across the board? I also thought I'd caught all 6 fish and returned them- then I get home and there's one zebra danio in the tank still?! Sneaky! I SWEAR I counted 6 in the container! Oh- there are also maybe 3 o4 four small snails living in there to keep them less stressed than in the puffer tank. None of the inhabitants are showing (or were before I returned most of them) any ill effects. There also were some blood worms in the sand but pretty much gone by this time as I would stir up the sand and the fish would go after them quickly.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 12:07 am
by Idontknow
mrgreen wrote:The readings were normal except nitrates which were huge- as in about 5
I think that a nitrate reading of 5 is not bad at all. <20 is usually normal.

I think I would be more worried if the reading was zero during cycling. It would mean the bacterias aren't changing the ammonia to nitrite to nitrates.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 11:17 am
by Myaj
Your store doesn't know what they are talking about.

The process is simple... waste produces ammonia as it rots, the ammonia is converted by bacteria to nitrites, which is somewhat less toxic, and the nitrites are converted by a different bacteria to nitrates, which can still cause problems if they start to build up to higher levels (20+).

There is no bacteria to remove nitrates, those can only be removed by water changes.. or if you have a massivly planted, high light, very productive planted tank, the plants can use them as fertilizer and bring them down. However that takes a lot of work to bring a tank to that level and isn't something the average fishkeeper does.

So yes, water changes bring your nitrates down, don't freak out at 5, that's just fine.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 3:43 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Read the fishless cycling article in the Library. It explains everything.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 3:45 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
P.S. Water changes don't start the cycle over. Most of the bacteria, about 90%, lives on surfaces (the substrate, the filter, decorations, etc.). Water changes remove waste, not bacteria, or at least not enough bacteria to make a difference.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Wed Jun 03, 2009 8:00 pm
by mrgreen
Whew! Thanks. :)

So I've done w/c since then. I also returned all the fish to the lfs. I took out the snails and removed as many blood worms as I could. Lots are still hiding in the sand and seem okay, though. I turned the water brackish (same as when I had the gsp) and then removed 1/4 of the water. This is so I could make a "land" area as I got a fiddler crab. Its also so that the heater and filter still run smoothly. (I think it is female- two small claws but if it molts and grows a big claw in the future I guess I'm wrong.) I moved a lot of the sand to one end for burrying and added a spot for hiding with plants and rocks. With 25% of the water missing, the filter is stirring up quite the bubbles. That's where I put the rocks - underneath- so the sandwouldn't constantly be worn away. I also put in two of my ghost shrimp from the other tank. They are so cute to watch. I put one in then after I caught the 2nd, I put it in. It was so funny to see the 2nd one walk up to the first and then they faced each other and looked like they were having a chat over coffee! Seems they eat most anything, but I added and algea wafer for the shrimp to work on for a while- and the crab.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Thu Jun 04, 2009 9:15 pm
by Pufferpunk
Glad there's no sick fish here... Moving to Gen Disc.

Re: Cycling my new tank- high Nitrates. Confused

Posted: Fri Jun 05, 2009 9:53 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
mrgreen wrote:Whew! Thanks. :)

So I've done w/c since then. I also returned all the fish to the lfs. I took out the snails and removed as many blood worms as I could. Lots are still hiding in the sand and seem okay, though. I turned the water brackish (same as when I had the gsp) and then removed 1/4 of the water. This is so I could make a "land" area as I got a fiddler crab. Its also so that the heater and filter still run smoothly. (I think it is female- two small claws but if it molts and grows a big claw in the future I guess I'm wrong.) I moved a lot of the sand to one end for burrying and added a spot for hiding with plants and rocks. With 25% of the water missing, the filter is stirring up quite the bubbles. That's where I put the rocks - underneath- so the sandwouldn't constantly be worn away. I also put in two of my ghost shrimp from the other tank. They are so cute to watch. I put one in then after I caught the 2nd, I put it in. It was so funny to see the 2nd one walk up to the first and then they faced each other and looked like they were having a chat over coffee! Seems they eat most anything, but I added and algea wafer for the shrimp to work on for a while- and the crab.
Sounds cute! :) I'd love to have a paludarium for hermit crabs one day, with just a small SW pool for them to wet their gills in a few times a day.