Page 1 of 2
I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:41 am
by Jase
No, I didn't really buy a sick puffer.
Though I am not a mod, admin, or anyone who's voice really matters, I would like to ask everyone to Please stop buying sick fish.
I do not suggest anyone buy a sick fish, and I wish others would stop advising to do so. this is why:
A) You only set yourself up for disappointment and heartache when the cute little guys does die. they usually do die.
B) It only supports stores that don't take care of the fish in the first place. why should they care about the health of their fish if somebody is going to come along and buy it anyway?
Thank you for your time.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 9:00 am
by puffertt77
Hey Jase
Although I agree with what you're saying my LFS always gets GSP's in and everytime they have I've seen at least 2 floating around in there with no fins and black. I've told them about it every time I've seen it and they don't really seem to care. The rest of the puffers in there always sell very quickly. My point is I think most LFS will buy more puffers no matter whether someone wants to save the sick one or not, they'll always get buyers for the ones that aren't sick.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 9:06 am
by Jase
I can't stop everyone everywhere from buying sick fish, but if you don't buy any, and tell the people you know and talk to not to buy any, and maybe they later suggest someone else doesn't buy sick fish, it might make a difference.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 9:09 am
by Jase
And like I said in the first post, don't advise people to buy a sick fish...
There should be a certain amount of accountability. It's not about what everyone else does, it's about each individual. Especially here on TPF where we are supposed to give out good advice.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 9:25 am
by marksrush
I totally agree. And I can speak from experience, because I've been guilty of this in the past.
I would comment, though, that just because you see some sick fish, don't assume that it's always the store's fault. For example at my store, if we have sick fish it's because they were shipped to us that way. But I see what you're saying because while we treat ours to get them being healthy if they come in sick, I suspect a lot of others don't.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 10:08 am
by lilgirlkat
I'm guilty (obviously).. but (and isn't there always a but?) I doubt this LFS will ever buy this kinda fish again. I've had more than one of their workers tell me that they won't be selling them anymore, so hopefully that's true.
I bought him because I couldn't stand to watch him waste away. He has the potential to be an amazing and beautiful fish.. how could I let that just waste away!?
btw -- all my pets (dogs, cats) have been sickly strays that I had to nurse back to health, so maybe that's just my thang..
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 10:11 am
by puffertt77
lilgirlkat wrote:I'm guilty (obviously).. but (and isn't there always a but?) I doubt this LFS will ever buy this kinda fish again. I've had more than one of their workers tell me that they won't be selling them anymore, so hopefully that's true.
I bought him because I couldn't stand to watch him waste away. He has the potential to be an amazing and beautiful fish.. how could I let that just waste away!?
btw -- all my pets (dogs, cats) have been sickly strays that I had to nurse back to health, so maybe that's just my thang..
Hey Lilgirlkat
To be honest when I was looking for a Mbu if I'd come across your sick little guy I would've also bought him
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 10:13 am
by Christemo
Amen. It just tells the stores to purchase more, and that people will buy them even if they're sick or not, so why not give them the crappiest conditions they can.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 2:32 pm
by yunachin
I agree as well. Its irresponsible. If a fish shop gets a sick fish in it is their responsibility to quarantine that fish and try to nurse it back to health. Not stick it in a tank hoping for it to sell and potentially making the others in the tank sick. If they see a number of sick fish coming in from the supplier its time to call the supplier or possibly find a new one. Buying sick animals in an attempt to "save them" costs more money and stress than buying a healthy one. Plus when buying sick fish it is 90% of the time an impulse buy which means the owner does not have the proper housing required for the fish therefore only adding fuel to the fire. The best thing you can do for this hobby is plan. If you cannot house an animal properly, don't buy it. I know it may be in someones best intentions but we have to remember that stunting a fish causes damage to it as well. Damage that cannot be seen, like stress and a drastically shorter lifespan. So in all actuality you aren't saving anything, just killing it off quicker.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 2:36 pm
by Woodbutcher
Jase wrote:No, I didn't really buy a sick puffer.
Though I am not a mod, admin, or anyone who's voice really matters, I would like to ask everyone to Please stop buying sick fish.
I do not suggest anyone buy a sick fish, and I wish others would stop advising to do so. this is why:
A) You only set yourself up for disappointment and heartache when the cute little guys does die. they usually do die.
B) It only supports stores that don't take care of the fish in the first place. why should they care about the health of their fish if somebody is going to come along and buy it anyway?
Thank you for your time.
I agree with Jase on all but one point.
IMO Just because a store has a sick fish doesn't mean they don't take care of their fish, anymore than we could say the people on this forum that have sick fish just don't take care of their fish. That being said, we will spend 4X the cost of a fish to save it a LFS cannot do that and be here for us.
To quote Jase --
Please stop buying sick fish.
IMO A newbe (like me)should never ever knowingly get a sick fish. However if a knowledgable fishkeeper can get the LFS to give them the fish and could save it, that would make a great gift for a newbe (like me

)
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 2:57 pm
by puffertt77
The LFS I go to up London (Aquatic Desighn Centre) treat all their sick fish out back. They will never sell sick fish to a customer no matter what
All fish are quarintined out back for at least a week and they must also be feeding before they're brought out to the shop front
I suppose some LFS just don't have the space and time to worry about sick fish
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 3:26 pm
by Pufferpunk
I'm sorry but I'm gonna have to disagree here...
Though I am not a mod, admin, or anyone who's voice really matters
YOUR VOICE
DOES MATTER!!!
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 4:19 pm
by yunachin
puffertt77 wrote:
I suppose some LFS just don't have the space and time to worry about sick fish
Then they are in the wrong business.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:01 pm
by Jase
Glad this got replies

and thanks PP.
I feel there really is no excuse for the idea that stores get sick fish in, so it's not their fault. Like has been stated, the fish should be quarantined until they are well.
Re: I bought a sick puffer...
Posted: Sat May 16, 2009 12:07 pm
by Myaj
Most GOOD stores will separate out sick fish, treat them and not sell them until they are healthy.
Most BAD stores could give two rips, and will sell it anyways or let it die.
A store with an owner/staff who cares and doesn't have the time/space to treat the fish themselves, will often be more than willing to give the fish to a customer that they know and trust.. in the hopes that they can bring the fish around and enjoy it instead of the store owner having to watch it waste away and die in the store.. either way, no profit.. by giving it to an established, knowledgable customer, the fish has a chance.
Which is a good reason why, even if you aren't shopping for fish, its still a good idea to support your local GOOD stores, buy your foods there, get to know the staff, ask them questions, discuss certain species with them, and stay friendly. If they look at you as a pain in their butt, they won't be happy to see you.. and its a heck of a lot more fun when they are happy to see you, and sometimes, good deals come your way because of it
