Page 1 of 2
Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 12:22 am
by emartin
I have a few Q's on keeping puffers and puffer species. I've been wanting to keep a species that sits in the 5"-18" range for TOTAL length.
Anyway despite some info I got from reading the PufferPedia section I have some questions for people who have kept brackish and freshwater puffers.
One, what species would you guys recommend? Currently I do not have a tank big enough available for any species yet (except for my 6ft 150g IF I ever get around to resealing it...) so any species I would get would likely be a small juvenile puffer likely off aquabid or something, ie one that would be available under 5" (largest tanks I have available now are only a 40g and a 75g. I do have a 6ft 150g but it needs to be resealed).
Also, what species are known for having super fast growing teeth? I know some puffer species the teeth (or beak) don't grow as fast and can be kept under growth control by regularly providing hard shelled foods like clams, snails, mussells, crayfish, crabs, etc. Otherwise I read that you have to regularly trim their beaks with a dremel after sedating them or just cut the beaks with cuticles, both of which I'd rather NOT do.
Lastly, with Brackish species, do all I have to do is all enough salt to get the right salinity for them at the same time I add freshwater, or just add some salt, or what? How sensitive are they to water quality?
For all the species, is a pH of 6 suitable?
One of the species I was looking at by the way T. lineatus, the Nile/Fahaka Puffer. Liveaquaria.com sells them I think...
~Ed
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 12:31 am
by Idontknow
I'd say reseal the 150g and go for the Fahaka, if you really want it.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 1:42 am
by katty
A 150gal tank is pretty darn big! 5" to 18" is a big range. As for brackish tanks, this site explains it pretty well imo:
http://badmanstropicalfish.com/brackish/brackish.html
I've had my baby Fahaka for about a week now and I absolutely love it. It's adorable, grows attached to you (when people come over, it tends to be a little timid but whenever I come up to the tank alone, it always comes and greets me), and has a great/interesting personality. If you have a 150gal tank, I would definitely go for a Fahaka.

From what I know, you don't have to worry about trimming their beak and just feeding them "crunchy" stuff will do.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 2:02 am
by emartin
katty wrote:A 150gal tank is pretty darn big! 5" to 18" is a big range. As for brackish tanks, this site explains it pretty well imo:
http://badmanstropicalfish.com/brackish/brackish.html
I've had my baby Fahaka for about a week now and I absolutely love it. It's adorable, grows attached to you (when people come over, it tends to be a little timid but whenever I come up to the tank alone, it always comes and greets me), and has a great/interesting personality. If you have a 150gal tank, I would definitely go for a Fahaka.

From what I know, you don't have to worry about trimming their beak and just feeding them "crunchy" stuff will do.
Yeah with whatever species I got with I do NOT want to have to trim the beak... That would be a big inconvenience for me!
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 3:09 am
by katty
Oh I dont blame you! That would seriously freak me out. Haha. I dont think I have the guts to do so even.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 3:15 am
by emartin
So does anybody know of any other species in that size range that don't need beak trimming as long as I feed hardshelled foods?
I'd like to keep a Fahaka but at the moment I'd like something that stays smaller to start out with.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 3:43 am
by Idontknow
South American Puffers are the ones that have really fast growing teeth that need to be trimmed regularly.
A GSP or a Ceylon will fit nicely into your 40g.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 4:13 am
by julianchan
Only thing about a GSP is that it will require high brackish to marine conditions when past 4". For the rest of them, I would say start them off in the big tank straight away, so you don't have to deal with stunting.
SAP's are about the only breed that seem to need trimming regardless of diet, the rest of them, from what I read, can have their teeth in check with a crunchy diet.
You could check out some lurkers that would do well in your 40g, some do get to a nice size....but honestly, I would seal that 150 and get it up and running.....if your heart is set on a big puffer, a Fahaka will be awesome, and you will only have to spend the money once...saving money in the long run...and having an awesome puffery friend from the get go.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 5:48 am
by emartin
julianchan wrote:Only thing about a GSP is that it will require high brackish to marine conditions when past 4". For the rest of them, I would say start them off in the big tank straight away, so you don't have to deal with stunting.
SAP's are about the only breed that seem to need trimming regardless of diet, the rest of them, from what I read, can have their teeth in check with a crunchy diet.
You could check out some lurkers that would do well in your 40g, some do get to a nice size....but honestly, I would seal that 150 and get it up and running.....if your heart is set on a big puffer, a Fahaka will be awesome, and you will only have to spend the money once...saving money in the long run...and having an awesome puffery friend from the get go.
Well honestly I'd LOVE to one day keep an Mbu puffer after seeing one recorded feeding in the wild in National Geographic's "Jewel of the Rift: Lake Tanganyika" video (you can see that clip here if you guys never saw it before:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-avuuJpMbK4&fmt=18 ) but I as a cichlid hobbyist don't like keeping fish particularly wild fish if I can't house them so they reach their full potential size. If I was to keep an mbu I'd personally want to give it an indoor pond at least a 7ftx5ft size with at least 2-3ft deep water but I don't have the space nor the money to build such a thing (especially since I'd want to construct at least one side for viewing).
So basically all the African and Asia Puffers are the ones that don't need trimming? That's good to hear.
When keeping the brackish types, would all I have to do is add enough Instant Ocean or something to get the right specific gravity for brackish conditions as I am adding fresh tap water to the tank or would I have to pre-mix the salt with the water?
Anyway what other species would do well in a 40g and what filtration would you recommend that the puffer wouldn't destroy? I was thinking Aquaclear Power Filters but I remember reading that Puffers don't like fast currents which leads me to believe it would have to be a model AC-50 or a model AC-70...
Thanks,
~Ed
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 7:15 am
by Christemo
Some puffers like fast currents, and I've never seen a puffer destroy a filter.
With a brackish system, if you were to just add water all the time, it would lower the SG. You have to premix the salt and water.
And about the mbu, I wouldn't purchase one until you had your whole system either built or in the middle of build. If you get it before, then things come up and your puffer is stuck in a smaller tank getting stunted.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 9:08 am
by marksrush
My vote would be for a Ceylon in your 75 (they get to 8"). I love mine, and they're one of the most beautiful puffers, in my opinion. It would need high-end brackish water, or eventually full marine conditions.
In your 40, how about a freshwater lurker like a Congo or a suvatti? It would be really cool if you could find a red or yellow Congo.
A pH of 6 would be a little acid for most freshwater species (gurus, am I right on this?); I'd think you'd want it closer to 6.8-7.0. Brackish to marine tanks will 8.0-8.4 pretty much no matter what you do, since you'll be using aragonite/crushed coral and salt, both of which naturally promote a pH in that range.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 9:24 am
by emartin
Christemo wrote:Some puffers like fast currents, and I've never seen a puffer destroy a filter.
With a brackish system, if you were to just add water all the time, it would lower the SG. You have to premix the salt and water.
And about the mbu, I wouldn't purchase one until you had your whole system either built or in the middle of build. If you get it before, then things come up and your puffer is stuck in a smaller tank getting stunted.
Well with the brackish system I was going to add the instant ocean for example directly to the aquarium while I am adding new freshwater. Is that fine?
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 4:01 pm
by Bogwoodbruce
Nice emporer cichlid in your avatar. We got 12 in at work, sold a few and they've grown loads, unreal growth rate and some agression to them too.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 4:24 pm
by trekenk
Well with the brackish system I was going to add the instant ocean for example directly to the aquarium while I am adding new freshwater. Is that fine?
No you need to pre mix.
Re: Freshwater and Brackish Puffer Fish Q's
Posted: Tue Apr 21, 2009 5:00 pm
by Pufferpunk
Is syour tap water really a pH of 6? If it is, you really need to speak to your water supply company--that's close to urine! Is there any ammonia/nitrite in your tap?