Page 1 of 2

puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 9:16 am
by BL4CK.1CE
i recently bought a puffer after falling in love with it at first glance. i brought it back home to put in my 110litre, 3ft tropical tank. in the tank i currently have 3 smallish sized angels, 2 bolivian rams, 1 pleco and 1 black molly. i was wondering wether the puffer will be ablle to function well in with these and also i would like to know the basics of puffer keeping. as far as i know it is a normal (non-dwarf) puffer.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 9:23 am
by side19
unless your puffer is a south American puffer i'll assume that you'll see your fish numbers dropping in the near future. take a look in the pufferpedia (is under the learn tab at the top of the page) and try to see which one of the freshwater puffers yours looks like. if you can't find it there take a look in the brackish section becuase sometimes brackish puffers are sold in fresh water. once you can ID it we might be able to help a little more. and welcome to the wonderful world of puffers.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 9:24 am
by crazedpuffer
[welcome]
Can you describe what your puffer looks like? See if you can find it in the pufferpedia.
Most puffers are very aggressive and fin nippers, and won't do well with those fish. THe only puffer that might possibly be okay would be a south american pufer.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:02 am
by BL4CK.1CE
i think, looking from the photos, it is a figure eight puffer allthough instead of the rings over the top of its body being yellow, they are the whiter colour of the underbelly.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:06 am
by BL4CK.1CE
it also looks simular to a Ceylon Puffer

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:06 am
by side19
ok, well first off you won't be able to keep that puffer in fresh water forever, they're actaully brackish puffers, so you'll want to set up at least a 10 gallon tank for him in the near future. as far as aggression i've found F8s to be all over the place. all the ones iv'e ever kept (granted Ra is my first that I've had for over a week) have all be very docile and passive, but i know people who have had ones that are out right killers. the light color could be stress, how new is he? take a look at the info in the pufferpedia and also look in the puffer library (also under the learn tab) and look at the article specifically about F8s, its very useful. how bit is he? and can you post some pictures? i love F8s. lol.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:27 am
by BL4CK.1CE
i will post a picture to be sure as soon as i can find the cable to connect my phone to the pc

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:27 am
by Christemo
Your angels will be gone soon, and the molly may have a few days before he gets killed.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:50 am
by marksrush
I don't know about angels, but I've had mollies and even a few glowlight tetras sharing a tank with my bronze puffer for quite some time now, and I never saw even a bit of aggression toward them. The mollies are still intact and doing fine, but I took out the tetras because, as the puffer grew, I was afraid they would start to look like a possible meal to him. Still, every puffer is an individual, and one puffer of the same species may act entirely the opposite from another one...so it's basically your experiment to conduct.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:51 am
by Christemo
The fins from the angels would sure look like dinner to any puffer.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:56 am
by BL4CK.1CE
well i have been watching closely and he hasn't even given any of the fish a second look yet but if he shows any aggressive behaviour then he will be sure to get isolated until i can find a better solution to his housing

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 10:58 am
by Pufferpunk
Please don't wait until your fish are shredded overnight! This WILL happen--it's only a matter of time. Puffers are not to be trusted, especially with long fins! Also, you have a brackish puffer & it needs a great deal of salt.

Please read the GSP article in our Library--care is identical for the Ceylon.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 11:27 am
by BL4CK.1CE
right, i have just sat and watched the fish swimming in the tank. i have also noted that rather than the puffer picking on the angels, it is quite the contrary and the angels are trying to nip at the puffers fins. for this i am going to isolate the puffer later on today until i have readied the tank in which i propose to put him into.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 11:28 am
by Pufferpunk
In addition to reading the GSP article in our Library, check out the Emergency Cycling one. It should give you ideas oh now to set up a cycled tank quicky for your new puffyfriend.

Re: puffer good decision with other fish?

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 1:02 pm
by BL4CK.1CE
ok, looking again i am now pretty sure that mine is a giant spotted puffer... i hadnt looked in the giant spotted puffer photo album before now and now that i have im pretty sure thats what ive got