Page 1 of 1

feeding time...

Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2009 7:39 pm
by lilgirlkat
I was just thinking about it... and I realized that I'm thawing all the puffers' food in brackish tank water. I have a feeling I know what the advice will be.. but I'm going to ask this question anyway.

I have 4 tanks. 2 brackish and 2 fresh. I've been feeding the fw tanks the food thawed in the bw. It doesn't seem to affect the DPs at all.

Will this affect them eventually? Are you guys going to shun me and tell me that I should be thawing/vitamin soaking in separate cups with water from each tank?

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2009 8:09 pm
by Dadof4
*SHUN*....The only real problem I can see is potential cross contamination of parasites or disease. The small amount of salt involved shouldn't hurt them.

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2009 8:50 pm
by edmlfc1
Dadof4 wrote:*SHUN*....The only real problem I can see is potential cross contamination of parasites or disease. The small amount of salt involved shouldn't hurt them.
I agree. If you get any kind of disease or parasite you will contaminate both tanks. Best to use two cups. :D

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2009 9:47 pm
by lilgirlkat
that's kinda what I was thinking. I always use *my* tank's water since I know it's clean and illness free (I do WCs, the bf does not...... bad bf!!).

I suppose I can start using different cups.

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:40 am
by Pufferpunk
I personally don't like the idea of feeding salty foods to FW fish. I'd thaw in FW.

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Fri Mar 27, 2009 11:35 am
by lilgirlkat
They're all separate now.. :)

and -- for that matter -- my bf won't even touch my tanks, since he gets yelled at every time he gets close. Last night he put a frozen cube of brine shrimp in his tank. No thawing, no vitamins. I was FURIOUS!! He was about to do it to mine, but I put a stop to that. Only thawed food soaked in vitamins for my fish, kthnx. He says I've gone mad.

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Fri Mar 27, 2009 10:59 pm
by marksrush
lilgirlkat wrote:...He says I've gone mad.
If you ask me, we're all nuts here. I mean come on, look at us: normal people have one tank; most of us have multiple tanks. Regular people fill their tanks with fish; we'll put one small fish in a large tank by itself without even thinking about it. We are obsessed with a single family of fishes. We name our fish and call them "cute", even as they mercilessly dismember an unlucky crayfish. We spend $5 on a fish, and then $1000+ keeping her. Our fish eat nothing but the best foods, while we subsist on Hamburger Helper and ramen noodles. We lie awake at night worrying when they're sick. We exhaust ourselves doing water changes and scraping algae, while dishes pile up in the sink. We love them deeply in spite of the fact that if they were given half a chance, many of them would bite our finger off and eat it.

These are not the habits of sane people. :D

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2009 2:57 am
by Nick
I thaw in tap water if a single batch of food is to be shared. I can't imagine that little chlorine having an ill effect. I used to thaw in tank water, but then I realized that I was draining the food through a net and rinsing it with tap anyway, so why bother. I haven't noticed any issues.

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2009 10:01 am
by Homer
marksrush wrote:
lilgirlkat wrote:...He says I've gone mad.
If you ask me, we're all nuts here. I mean come on, look at us: normal people have one tank; most of us have multiple tanks. Regular people fill their tanks with fish; we'll put one small fish in a large tank by itself without even thinking about it. We are obsessed with a single family of fishes. We name our fish and call them "cute", even as they mercilessly dismember an unlucky crayfish. We spend $5 on a fish, and then $1000+ keeping her. Our fish eat nothing but the best foods, while we subsist on Hamburger Helper and ramen noodles. We lie awake at night worrying when they're sick. We exhaust ourselves doing water changes and scraping algae, while dishes pile up in the sink. We love them deeply in spite of the fact that if they were given half a chance, many of them would bite our finger off and eat it.

These are not the habits of sane people. :D
I think your right, we're definitely all nuts!

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2009 10:02 am
by Homer
marksrush wrote:
lilgirlkat wrote:...He says I've gone mad.
If you ask me, we're all nuts here. I mean come on, look at us: normal people have one tank; most of us have multiple tanks. Regular people fill their tanks with fish; we'll put one small fish in a large tank by itself without even thinking about it. We are obsessed with a single family of fishes. We name our fish and call them "cute", even as they mercilessly dismember an unlucky crayfish. We spend $5 on a fish, and then $1000+ keeping her. Our fish eat nothing but the best foods, while we subsist on Hamburger Helper and ramen noodles. We lie awake at night worrying when they're sick. We exhaust ourselves doing water changes and scraping algae, while dishes pile up in the sink. We love them deeply in spite of the fact that if they were given half a chance, many of them would bite our finger off and eat it.

These are not the habits of sane people. :D
I think your right, we're definitely nuts!

Re: feeding time...

Posted: Sat Mar 28, 2009 1:03 pm
by ryverrat
I thaw in dechlorinate tap water with vitamins for all my tanks (FW,BW and SW). Use tweezers to put food in tanks (disinfect with hydrogen peroxide and clean water rinse between tanks to prevent contamination). This way I have only 3-4 cups of food to thaw (8 tanks- won't all eat the same things- worse than trying to get lunch for a girl scout troop). Thanks marksrush, I need to do the dishes before the water changes this week. :roll: