Page 1 of 1

redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 5:01 am
by saram82
hi, I've been wanting to start a puffer tank for awhile, i'd been planning on getting a 10 or 20 gallon tank with 2 or 3 dwarf puffers and maybe some danios or barbs since i have read that dp's can sometimes coexist with them. someone at my lfs recently showed me some redeye puffers (c lorteti) and now i really want one. ive been doing a lot of research online (though there really isn't much out there on this variety) and have found that this is an extremely aggressive type of puffer and cannot be trusted with any other fish, not even its own kind, not without taking a huge risk. so, i am interested in getting like a 3, 5 or 6 gallon tank and keeping one by itself (they get to be about 2.5" max). would one of these tank sizes be adequate? i really don't want to devote an entire 10 gallon tank to one fish, as my space is very limited and if i get a 10 gallon i'd like to have a small community in it. i know the rule of thumb is 1 inch of fish per gallon but puffers are more intelligent than most fish and i dont want a sad fish. i really dont even like the idea of keeping a fish completely alone but it seems that these guys are too much of a homicide risk to give them any tank mates, it seems that they'll even attack their mates when they arent breeding. does anyone know anything about these guys? the guy at my lfs seemed to think that a female would be fine in a community tank with dwarf puffers as tank mates (that was what he was suggesting when he showed them to me) but nothing i have read has led me to think that that could possibly be a good idea. anyway, i'd love to have one in a tiny desktop size tank to keep me company while im at my computer, but again, i dont want an unhappy fish. any thoughts? this will actually be my first fishkeeping endeavor since trying my hand with goldfish as a little kid, though i have experience with many, many other pet varieties.

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 6:05 am
by s13maximo
I think if you would actually have done a lot of research, you would have read that those tank sizes are rediculous... Think about something of the 20gallon size for keeping one of these. But to be sure check the pufferpedia please! And don't get a fish like this if you're buying a 6gal tank....

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 7:05 am
by Troender
I'm afraid you can't keep a lorteti at that tank size. You won't find c. lorteti in the PufferPedia here, but the care is the same as for c. irrubesco. The smallest tank you can keep a single lorteti in, is in 20 G. It is possible to keep them as a pair, but you must alway be prepared to split them, as they can kill each other. A heavily planted tank is needed. And if you are keeping more than one, you need more space than 20 G.

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 1:43 pm
by saram82
s13maximo you really need to actually read people's posts before you decide to be condescending. i said that i tried to research them but was unable to find much info online. a couple of sources online said that a pair could go in a 10g tank, but nothing about keeping a single fish. and the guy at my lfs seemed to think that one would do fine in a 10g community tank, which i have discovered is incorrect. i never said i was planning on getting a 6g tank, it was just an idea and i wanted to know if it would work before i bought anything. i am still planning on setting up my 10g dwarf puffer tank, but i dont have the space to have two 10-20g tanks so thats why i was curious if it was possible to put one in a small tank. as i said before, this is my first tank and i am trying to research it to death so that i don't put out a lot of money and then have it fail. why be mean to someone who's trying to get information so that she can prevent doing the wrong thing?

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 2:06 pm
by kelsi.nikoel
Rule #1: Dont trust the guy/girl at the LFS :)

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 2:39 pm
by kelsi.nikoel
If you are wanting a small tank with a puffer in it, get a dwarf puffer. They require 5 gal.

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:36 pm
by ceech1
its good that you are trying to find out info so it is this site has some very good info in the libary so it does.i have a south american puffer which i was misinformed about in my lfs.he needs a friend .going to get him one next week.20 gallons would be good but just make sure the tank has cycled before ya add the puffers.ya could get some zebra dianos to cycle it with as they are tough.but the puffers are very sensative to no2 and amonia and will only die if your tank is not cycled.you are also going to have to think about getting a small tank to breed snails in to help with the waring of there teeeth.my fella has to have his teeth trimmer by hand every 6 months so make sure ya take this into account before you commit yourself.i also feed my ones blood worm live and frozen blood worms aswell as snail and i am trying to get him to eat fronzen shrimps.good luck with your new tank.

Re: redeye (lorteti) tank size?

Posted: Sun Mar 22, 2009 1:51 pm
by kelsi.nikoel
ceech1 wrote:its good that you are trying to find out info so it is this site has some very good info in the libary so it does.i have a south american puffer which i was misinformed about in my lfs.he needs a friend .going to get him one next week.20 gallons would be good but just make sure the tank has cycled before ya add the puffers.ya could get some zebra dianos to cycle it with as they are tough.but the puffers are very sensative to no2 and amonia and will only die if your tank is not cycled.you are also going to have to think about getting a small tank to breed snails in to help with the waring of there teeeth.my fella has to have his teeth trimmer by hand every 6 months so make sure ya take this into account before you commit yourself.i also feed my ones blood worm live and frozen blood worms aswell as snail and i am trying to get him to eat fronzen shrimps.good luck with your new tank.
[welcome]

I am thinking about getting a couple SAPs and i was wondering how difficult it is to trim their teeth, and also if you have any techniques that you use to trim them.