Page 1 of 1

New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 3:03 pm
by Katydid
Hello all!

Im a former travel Nurse, who has just taken a permanent job, so now I can have an aquarium again! The last one I had was strictly goldfish, so not a huge amount of maintainence required...(just a ton of water changes.) so Im really a newbie.

When looking at fish at a local fish store I really liked the little puffers I saw (not really sure if they were GSP or the figure 8 hard to tell, since the store guys had no clue). They all swam right up to the glass to greet me etc... AsI learned more about puffers, I was disappointed to find that they can be so aggressive. My first idea of having a tank full of colorful fish and puffers immediately came to a screeching halt.

So I am wondering if there really are any type of smaller puffers that would co-exist with a few other fish. Ive heard that some do well with faster fish, barbs tetras or glass fish?

I was thinking of a 30-40 gallon tank. getting set up and cycling in April, fish then in may or so....

Any advice really appreciated. Its all a bit confusing to me.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 3:29 pm
by powerpuffer
I first purchased my two figure eight puffers and thought they should have tank mates. It was almost a year later that I realized that I could not keep them together with my two Columbian sharks. They just kept nipping at their fins and the sharks were constantly nervous. Rather than get rid of my fish I made I divider in my tank from a product called egg-crate. This allows me to have the same brackish water that they both need, good water flow, and best of all, I only have to maintain one tank. Maybe it's an option for you.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:06 pm
by Sponge bob
Depends. Do you wanna do fresh water, brackish or salt?
South American Puffers are good freshwater community.
You can do a few of those and some tetras. They need there teeth trimmed though.
I like dwarf puffers. You can do a ton of those in a 30-40 gallon tank.3-5 Gallons each for the dwarf's. there freshwater.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:32 pm
by Katydid
Thanks for your fast responses.
Both are pretty good ideas. I'm leaning towards fresh water as I think its easier to maintain. (I had a former job of maintaining a ton of snails in a lab and filtering sea water was not really that much fun.)

I was thinking dwarf or the green spotted... its great to look through the pufferpedia to get an idea of the actual size, because like I said, pet store guy....he really thought they would stay that teeny size.... LOL

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:43 pm
by Sponge bob
Hehe
30 gallon can hold one GSP which they go brackish then into saltwater.
40 gallon can hold one gsp and extra goodies(rocks,fake plants,caves. ETC)
fresh water.personally I like Suvattis and congos.
There very cool.
Thatfishplace.com got in some congos

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 8:12 pm
by zombiefetus
Brackish water is actually pretty easy to maintain. If you're looking to keep a community tank I'd suggest either F8's (low end brackish- ug.php/v/PufferPedia/Brackish/T_Biocellatus/) or SAPs (Freshwater- ug.php/v/PufferPedia/Freshwater/C_Asellus/). I've never kept SAPs, but I hear they do well with tankmates and are generally nonaggerssive, they do require teeth trimming every so often though, so make sure that's something you'd feel comfortable doing before considering them.

F8's can be kept with other low-end brackish fish like mollies, bumblebee gobies, Orange Chromide Cichlids, etc. They need 15gallons per puffer, but if you went with like a 20gallon tank you could keep an F8 a pair of mollies and a few bumblebee gobies.

Green Spotted Puffers can be very aggressive and need 30gallons to themself. They're also a high-end brackish fish and most people choose to keep them in full marine conditions since it's easier to maintain. They cannot be kept in freshwater or low-end brackish water for very long. I have a website on them (link in my signature- though I haven't really been able to update lately).

Dwarf Puffers are awesome little fish. Totally freshwater and amusing to watch swim around the tank. I know some people who keep them with tetras and some faster fish like danios, but it's generally not recommended and there's always a risk your little puffers will kill any tankmates in there.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 8:32 pm
by ROTTEN76
F8's are awewsome puffers, I keep mine with Knight gobies. Not the most colorful fish, but very intereting and beautiful.
I wouldn't keep danios with DP's, tried it once and the danios tormented the DP'S. But I guess it depends on the puffers. Just wanted to give a thumbs up to knight gobies, If I could tell them apart, I'd name them.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:27 am
by Katydid
OK, some good ideas.

I'm thinking maybe a 30 gal tank with 2-3 DP's and then 1-2 cichlids or one plecos (Smaller variety thought here are some really cool bigger ones) ... ... and wait and see if the puffers get nippy, I can put in the divider.

Does that sound about right. Trying to figure out if I want sand gravel or a combo of sand and gravel....
oh so many choices!

Anyone know a good store in the Orlando FL area????

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 2:09 pm
by zombiefetus
I wouldn't do cichlids with DPs, unless you went with smaller/calmer cichlids like blue rams. Just think of the damage a DP would do if the cichlid decided to try to eat it. You'd have to pry a very frightened, inflated puffer from it's mouth, and someone would definitely end up dead.

I don't know how well plecos do with DPs, I know most people choose Otos over Plecos with DPs, but that may just be because they usually use smaller tanks.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Thu Mar 19, 2009 2:02 am
by sarina23
A brackish tank is always fun and pretty simple if you wanted to do something different. I have kept knight gobies, monos and chromides with my GSP and Ceylon. There hasn't ever been a problem, granted that the monos past away...but not from the puffers! I do kinda want a DP tank also though, thinking about that soon. My boyfriend and I have a cichlid tank with 6"+ guys that would swallow a DP whole, lol, so you don't want those two to mix. Yes, a dwarf ram cichlid would probably be good in a DP tank. There is a bolivian ram in my moms community tank and the plattys have had tons of babies and he never tries to eat them, and they are teeeeeny!

Good luck with your ideas =) Oh ps, all my tanks have sand except the community one...and when I do tank changes I hate doing it on the gravel! I don't know why, it just seems to me the sand is cleaner and keeps it better in there.

Re: New puffer aquarium....

Posted: Thu Mar 19, 2009 6:26 pm
by Katydid
the more I thought about it the Cichilds and DPs in the tank would be sort of like Monday night wrestling, but worse.

Im sort of looking for a tank on Freecycle (They seem to show upfrequently in the 10-20 gallon variety) and then I'll have to make some decisions....