Page 1 of 2
I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:18 pm
by CaptainMorgan_SOS
So i was looking around online for a new filter for the 55 gallon i will be setting up soon (hopefully for SAPs, a swarm of Dwarf Puffers, or even a group of Figure 8 Puffers. Not mixed togetherof course, well maybe some SAPs and some Dwarfs if possible

) and i just happen to come upon this site that sells a "Zero Water Change System." The site claims that the system will eliminate the need for water changes and will maintain a safe, healthy environment for your fish, fresh or saltwater

... Is this too good to be true? Usually if I have to ask, it is

.
Here is the site:
http://www.hiq-usa.com/zero_water_exhan ... on_kit.asp
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:26 pm
by Dadof4
I would have to say....no. Too good to be true. Can it be done? Possibly, with chemicals and such but I don't think anything can replace water changes.
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:42 pm
by Jase
Of coarse it works! for about one week.
You still need to do WCs, but their system does have plenty of filtration to help. Is it worth $100? no way.
I have seen reverse flow undergravel a few times lately, is this new or have I just not noticed it? I'm guessing it keeps that wonderful UGF gunk out?
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 10:08 pm
by CaptainMorgan_SOS
the reverse flow undergravel filtration is a cool idea i think, it pshes all the leftover food and poo to the top for mechanical filtration, so i may lust look for a reverse flow system. But i really like sand, and i heard puffers do too so that wouldn't work i guess... i'll keep checking into this though.
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 10:13 pm
by CaptainMorgan_SOS
well, actually i think i'll just stick to water changes, even though when i get deployed, this system, if it worked, would be very nice for the wife since i won't be there to take care of the fish... she's afraid that when i leave for 6 months, all the fish will die
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 11:21 pm
by Jase
It depends what puffer you get whether sand makes a difference. other than I think it is more aesthetically pleasing. UGF are not my favorite, but they do work. If you teach the mrs how to do a water change, then she should be fine.

Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 12:23 am
by Pufferpunk
Sounds like you have 6 months to teach the wife how to do WC!

Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 1:37 am
by DRRT
i actually know someone who has a perfectly balanced system in which all he need to add is various supplements, clean out a couple filters and feed the tank once a week. of course this guy has a degree in physics and took a bunch of chem and bio classes. his reef is amazing, he put a lot of time and effort in planning and implement his reef, but he can't just go and add whatever he wants to the tank. there are no whimsical purchases when you have a set up like his.
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 1:50 am
by Pufferpunk
He NEVER does any WC?
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 6:54 pm
by edmlfc1
Someone else told me they "never" do a water change. I asked how they keep the nitrates down and she said she just adds bacteria as needed. All she does is top off. I just can't believe that would work.

She said fish tanks are to be enjoyed and not work. She was shocked that I do 50% water changes each week.

Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 9:52 pm
by DRRT
nope. all he does is add distilled water when needed. but like i said, he doesn't add anything to the tank but vitamins, mineral, etc and feeds it only once a week. its a large system with a large sump, frag tank, algal screen, plenum system. i think he said this was his third attempt (and the only one that worked) at a no w/c system
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 1:48 am
by Nick
I've heard of tanks like this, but not that last more than a few years, even if set up by absolute experts. edmlfc1, I'd guess your friend that "never" does water changes hasn't had a tank for more than a year or two - I've seen tanks hang on that long at my job with just topoffs, before the entire system starts crashing, piece by piece. The fish so slowly acclimate to the filthy water that they may go a long time before showing how much damage it is doing. Often the people that do the "no water changes" buy new fish every few weeks, gradually replacing the old ones as their immune systems break down and they die "for no reason."
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 7:49 am
by edmlfc1
your friend that "never" does water changes hasn't had a tank for more than a year or two -I'd guess
Sorry Nick, she's not a friend of mine. Just someone I spoke too a couple of times. I thought about calling her to find out more about this no water change thing she called an eco system (not sure if I spelled it right) but I never did. We were just talking fish one day and the subject came up about w/c and that's when she told me that. I have never heard of anyone else doing it until I read this post.

Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 12:49 pm
by Nick
I've heard many claims to having an ecosystem in an aquarium, but somehow I would suspect to actually work like a real ecosystem, it you would need 100's of gallons per fish even for small ones.
Re: I wonder if this thing really works...
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 5:38 pm
by DRRT
in response to what nick was saying, i haven't talked to my friend in about a year and at the time, he had had it set up for about two years. unfortunately i've lost touch with him, so i have no way of knowing how his system is doing. i could possibly go and try and find him, but it would very difficult know that i'm in a different state altogether.