Page 1 of 1

Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 7:40 pm
by puffertt77
Hello All

Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 7:50 pm
by riggers
Yes. :D

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 7:50 pm
by riggers
Wait, what are you using it for?

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 8:16 pm
by Myaj
Er, I guess that depends on what you want.

A sump is very good, it adds water volume, gives you a place to have a veggie filter if you want it, etc.

It doesn't really have the mechanical filtration though, because if anything got plugged up you'd have a big, overflowing mess.

So it is good, yes. Does it do the same job as an external filter, no, not really. Both would be ideal ;)

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 9:03 pm
by puffertt77
I have a big external filter at the moment for my freshwater Tropical tank and it works fine

I just wondered why some people have a sump

A sump is mostly used on Marine isn't it?

I've seen a 10ft w x 4ft d x 2ft h tank for sale, it comes with a 6ft sump and 2 Koi filters and bog wood etc, only thing is it's £1200

What are Kio pumps/filters I think they're probably big filters used in Kio Carpe Ponds?!

This tank would be perfect for Naboo my Mbu :)

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 9:13 pm
by edmlfc1
I use a sump on my marine tank and I love it. It gives you a place to hide all your equipment, more water volume, a place to grow plants, easy to clean, and from what I hear adds more oxygen to the water.

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 9:59 pm
by Myaj
Sumps can be used on any tank.

The biggest benefit of course is the increase in water volume of course.

But yes, its a good place to hide things like heaters, especially if you have fish that like to, ahem, "play" with objects in their tank. And it also has the added bonus of maintaining the water level in your display, all water levels that drop from evaporation will show up in the sump. Of course, this means you have to keep a close eye on it and top off, don't forget about it or your return pump can run dry.

Veggie filters can be used, which is a huge bonus for those that have plant eating species and otherwise would not be able to enjoy the benefits of live plants. And you can even do reverse lighting (light turns on in the sump when the display light turns off) so when your display plants stop photosythesising for the day, the ones in your sump are just getting started, so you have plants working to remove the organics 24 hours a day pretty much.

I think they have more benefits to saltwater tanks because they are good places to put ugly equipment like skimmers, and perfect for keeping a healthy pod colony out of reach of hungry fish (but the pods still get ocassionally sucked up into the main tank, providing the fish with a snack). That sort of thing.

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 11:00 pm
by puffertt77
Extra water volume, I guess that's good at keeping the Puffers Bioload more diluted right?

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 11:02 pm
by taureandragon76
puffertt77 wrote:Extra water volume, I guess that's good at keeping the Puffers Bioload more diluted right?
Yes. IMO sumps are the best method for filtration on larger tanks.

Re: Is using a Sump better than a Big External Filter?

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 11:33 pm
by puffertt77
Thanks all for your help