Page 1 of 1
Hardwater?
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 10:25 am
by busybones
I was wondering (this could be a silly question) but how conserned should i be about water hardness? And how to i get it "softer" without hurting my fish? I do 50%-70% water changes in all of my tanks 1-2 times per week. Thanks for your help!
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 12:52 am
by busybones
hummm...so i shouldn't worry? nobody has written so I'm guessing it isn't a huge concern..
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 1:40 am
by Jase
Or we're waiting for someone more knowledgeable to come help you. I have hard water, but have no problems. still wait for some more opinions.

Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 7:48 am
by busybones
Everything else looks good, and i test often. Doesn't seem to cause any problems. Sorry i'm so impatient! haha
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 9:44 am
by fishlady1958
just how hard is your water parameter?
i think if your little aquatic friends are doing well, then they must've acclimated to it well.....
i have 2 tanks that i purposely lower the ph with lots of plants and driftwood...and occasionally almond leaves in the filter...but i keep discus and rams in those tanks...and they thrive better in softer water....so i guess it really all depends on what you have in the tanks and how long they've been in the hard water environment...but then again....i'm a rookie compared to most on here.....

Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 10:18 am
by busybones
No worries i'm a rookie too

I'm at work now, but on the strips i use it says very hard or something like that i'll give you the #'s when i get home. The only thing i have in that tank is my Fahaka, I just planted a hornswort and some small grass type stuff the other day. I do have a fully cycled tank that i'd like to find a good puffer for and it's also hard (the same as the big tank) and it's been set up for months (only has a guppy, few pond snails, fiddler crab, and a alge eater in it). I just want to make sure my fish are healthy and like to do what i can to make sure. Thanks so much for you help!
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 12:20 pm
by Iliveinazoo
busybones wrote:No worries i'm a rookie too

I'm at work now, but on the strips i use it says very hard or something like that i'll give you the #'s when i get home. The only thing i have in that tank is my Fahaka, I just planted a hornswort and some small grass type stuff the other day. I do have a fully cycled tank that i'd like to find a good puffer for and it's also hard (the same as the big tank) and it's been set up for months (only has a guppy, few pond snails, fiddler crab, and a alge eater in it). I just want to make sure my fish are healthy and like to do what i can to make sure. Thanks so much for you help!
A puffer will eat your fiddler crab. Is your fiddler in brackish water? he/she will prefer a salinity above 1.005.
Some fish like discus require slightly acidic (soft) water.
Some fish like marines and marine invertebrates require harder water.
most fish do not seem to be all that bothered with water hardness.
Live plants, peat and wood i believe will reduce water hardness. (most live plants will love water changes with hardwater).
Crushed coral, and a mix of calcium, magnessium and potassium increase water hardness
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 12:37 pm
by Christemo
The only issue I've seen with hard water is that the pH level is usually higher than 8. I just use the pH corrector tablets and it usually clears it right up.
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 12:52 pm
by busybones
Iliveinazoo wrote:busybones wrote:No worries i'm a rookie too

I'm at work now, but on the strips i use it says very hard or something like that i'll give you the #'s when i get home. The only thing i have in that tank is my Fahaka, I just planted a hornswort and some small grass type stuff the other day. I do have a fully cycled tank that i'd like to find a good puffer for and it's also hard (the same as the big tank) and it's been set up for months (only has a guppy, few pond snails, fiddler crab, and a alge eater in it). I just want to make sure my fish are healthy and like to do what i can to make sure. Thanks so much for you help!
A puffer will eat your fiddler crab. Is your fiddler in brackish water? he/she will prefer a salinity above 1.005.
Some fish like discus require slightly acidic (soft) water.
Some fish like marines and marine invertebrates require harder water.
most fish do not seem to be all that bothered with water hardness.
Live plants, peat and wood i believe will reduce water hardness. (most live plants will love water changes with hardwater).
Crushed coral, and a mix of calcium, magnessium and potassium increase water hardness
The crab is currently in a tank without any puffers in it, he is in light brackish water right now and spends most of his time out of the water (this is a temp. set up for him he's going to be moved soon) I didn't realize he needed more salt so i'll keep that in mind when setting up his new tank. I have added some new plants into the Fahaka tank so maybe that will help. I use the same water (from the tap) when doing changes and pool filter sand for my subtrate. I'm going to keep doing checks and post my last readings as soon as i get home. The test showed my ph to be in the high 7's maybe my strips are junk...Thanks so much for helping "crab-man" will appreciate it lol
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 7:44 pm
by Jase
Christemo wrote:The only issue I've seen with hard water is that the pH level is usually higher than 8. I just use the pH corrector tablets and it usually clears it right up.
I wouldn't recommend quick change tabs or liquids, because ph swings are more harmful than steady high ph. peat, plants, and driftwood are ok in my book, because they make gradual change.
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 8:18 pm
by busybones
Yeah i wouldn't add any kind of Ph changing chemicals no way
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 8:37 pm
by edmlfc1
I wouldn't try to change it. They can adapt to your water rather it's hard or soft, as long as you don't do changes to it.

Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Sun Feb 08, 2009 6:41 pm
by Myaj
Stable water conditions are much better for fish than trying to constantly adjust them.
Unless you have a delicate fish or are trying to bring on breeding conditions, most of the time hardness is not a problem, as long as its not fluctuating.
Re: Hardwater?
Posted: Sun Feb 08, 2009 7:31 pm
by busybones
thanks guys! your alot of help!