Page 1 of 1
and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 6:19 am
by Homer
Well after reading all these threads about people complaining about Kmart conditions on here, i've finally decided to go hunting for some pics of Hong Kong's Tung Choi Street, also known as "gold fish street" which is basically like a huge out-door fish market to show you just how bad conditions are over here for most of the fish in the pet trade.. Although, let me just say, not all shops are this bad, but a good 99% are...
Incase your wondering, these pics were all found off google...
although you can't really tell by the pic, but both sides of the street are actually covered in fish stores...
here's how most the fish for sale are displayed, hanging in bags up on racks all day long till some one buys them...
Sadly, this is not an un-common sight, lots of large fish in a reasonably small tank...

Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 7:37 am
by Christemo
They also raise cats and dogs for fur coats over there.
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 7:54 am
by Homer
^ I think your thinking of China, since Hong Kong doesn't raise cats and dogs for fur coats... at least not that i'm aware of...
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 12:46 pm
by Pufferpunk
Isn't Hong Kong in China?
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 1:31 pm
by Agnate
It is, but Hong Kong was developed as a free market city and was only reclaimed by China with the agreement that it would remain a free market city. For quite a while, Hong Kong was under completely different laws and regulations than the rest of China, if I'm not mistaken.
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 1:59 pm
by DRRT
this is true, britian lost control over it in 1999 i think
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 2:23 pm
by riggers
I think it was 1997
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 2:08 am
by Homer
Agnate wrote:It is, but Hong Kong was developed as a free market city and was only reclaimed by China with the agreement that it would remain a free market city. For quite a while, Hong Kong was under completely different laws and regulations than the rest of China, if I'm not mistaken.
DRRT wrote:this is true, britian lost control over it in 1999 i think
riggers wrote:I think it was 1997
Well, it depends on how you look at it, Hong Kong itself is an island near China, not exactly IN China so to speak... and yes HK was basically run under British Rule till 1997, at which time China took over Hong Kong, leaving it a free market as Agnate said... then in 1999, if i rmb correctly is when China took over Macau, from the Portuguese gov.
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 3:08 am
by Jase
Even though that's a bit ridiculous (hanging in a bag all day), I'd kinda like to see all these things. The culture is so incredibly different!
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 3:22 am
by julianchan
Dont forget the color injected fish there too....
But then again, I am sure if you ask people from HK who they are.....its a whole different story than how cut and dry we make the borders...
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 3:37 am
by Homer
^ I'm from HK... and still living here, although i'm not sure you meant by your last post???
Any way, i mean as bad as that place is for fish, its basically the ONLY place in HK where you can find a wide variety of fish for sale, and for pretty cheap prices... and by cheap I mean a bag of around 50 - 100 neon tetras sell for as little as HKD $20 - $40 which works out to be about USD $2.50 - $5.10, or to help put things into perspective a bit more, you can buy 4 GSP's at about an inch or so long for about USD $2.50...
But i'd have to say the biggest problem with 99% of the shops there is A) a lot of the fish get majorly stressed from being man handled all day, and the fact that they (the shops) have NO IDEA what they are selling half the time... like if you walk into any shop that sells GSPs and ask about them they will all tell you the same thing... they live in PURELY F/W and ONLY eat blood worms...
Re: and you thought Kmart was bad...
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 4:18 am
by recombinantrider
I was born and raised in Hong Kong, and I just learned about this "Gold fish street" in Mongkok when I went home for a visit a few years ago. To be honest, I get slightly offended sometimes when I am generalized as "someone from China" because honestly, the culture in Hong Kong is REALLY different from that in mainland China. We've been under the British rule for close to 150 years, until 1997. We had the luxury to do free trade with almost any nation in the world, and we have our own government (no communism!). We still kinda have a separate government from China although obviously the mainland government is having so much control behind closed doors nowadays. But on the facade, HK still kinda acts like a separate entity with a separate government.
I am a citizen of HK, but when I decide to visit mainland China, I need to get a visa! Also, I cannot relate myself to the Chinese from mainland either, because we've been exposed to such different mentalities on so many levels.....
Anyhoo, yeah, those fish in Mongkok are really dirt cheap. I know for a fact that they are 99.999999% not going to tanks big enough for them because:
1) rent/properties in Hong Kong are super expensive. 7 million people are crammed in about 400 sq miles. If you think living in places like Manhattan, Boston or Los Angeles expensive, Hong Kong is way worse. I used to share a bedroom about the size of a king size bed (yes, that's the size of the WHOLE ROOM) with my sister until I was 18. When she went to bed, I could not sit by the desk to do my homework. And we're a moderately well-off family.... So the point is, square footage is not easy to come by, for human, or for a fish tank.
2) Mentality--people are impatient and always bombarded with the latest technology and fashion. They want the newest, and changes, all the time. If a fish gets sick, they're not gonna spend a whole lot of energy to get to the root of the problem. Just get a new one, which is easier to deal with then fixing a problem.