Page 1 of 2
Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 12:05 pm
by mysifier
Hi,
I have just bought a 100 litre tank for my C. Irrubesco Slugsy, I want to put lots of live plants in this tank but I have no idea what substrate to use. I like the look of Fluorite black sand but it is so expensive! Can anyone suggest a good, cheap substrate?
Thanks

Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 12:53 pm
by pinkfloydpuffer
I use eco-complete. I'm not sure if you'd call it cheap though, but I am very happy with it.
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 2:03 pm
by Pandora114
I heard good stuff about Flourite. I plan on adding it to my substrate next month
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:06 pm
by Jase
Eco-complete is pretty good too.
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:38 pm
by plurmaster
i use eco complete,flourite,floramax...all have ups and down here goes
Flourite- need to be rinse good due to massive residual dust. Might take little work to get all the dirt and goo out but over all is pretty good for plants.
Eco-complete- Extremely good with plants. Lots of nutrients in the substrate. Dont believe the hype about beneficial bacterial that comes with it. If any most already dead inside the bag. I also find that lots of people said dont rinse it but if you dont you'll find this brown dust sitting on top of the substrates. Im having a hard time getting rdi of it even with vaccuming.
FloraMax- Just like flourite but made by carribea sea. The problem is the subsrates is pretty big. Is hard to hold plnats in place.
You can also try ADA aqua soil which i heard nothing but good reviews but kinda expensvie for starters. I would recommand for you to upgrade later when you learn everything about planted tanks.
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 7:14 pm
by mysifier
Thanks for the help guys

I just picked up my tank (which I bought on Ebay) and it came with more stuff than I thought yey! I thought I was just bidding on the tank and hood, but it came complete with filter and heater too! all that for £40, I'm so excited about setting it up!

Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 9:48 pm
by By_a_coo
If you will set up a planted tank, we aquatic gardeners, recommend one layer (3-4cm) of potting soil and a second layer (6cm) of any inert sand, just like filter pool san or playsand covering that fertil soil.
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 2:13 am
by Jase
By_a_coo wrote:If you will set up a planted tank, we aquatic gardeners, recommend one layer (3-4cm) of potting soil and a second layer (6cm) of any inert sand, just like filter pool san or playsand covering that fertil soil.
that sounds much cheaper. Is that just regular potting soil like for house plants? would you do this dry first?
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 9:32 am
by By_a_coo
Yes, it's too much cheap. You can find potting soil at flower/garden shop. Just set the first layer of potting soil (don't have to wet the soil), then cover it with a good layer of any inert sand. This soil is very fertil and provides all nutrients.
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 8:50 pm
by Jase
Thanks for that tip

Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 6:59 pm
by Pandora114
By_a_coo wrote:Yes, it's too much cheap. You can find potting soil at flower/garden shop. Just set the first layer of potting soil (don't have to wet the soil), then cover it with a good layer of any inert sand. This soil is very fertil and provides all nutrients.
Holy cow, there's potting soil in a community spot close to my back yard! So...I can get this, then put gravel over top and it'll be all good?
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:12 pm
by Myaj
Assuming you are 100% sure there's no sort of fertilizers or any of those little bead things that are supposed to hold in moisture in it.
I personally prefer EcoComplete, easy to use, no rinsing and the black color is great, especially with a black background. I have used Flourite many times in the past and HATE dealing with it, that's a lot of rinsing, rinsing and more rinsing, and it gets stuck under your fingernails!
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:24 pm
by Pandora114
Myaj wrote:Assuming you are 100% sure there's no sort of fertilizers or any of those little bead things that are supposed to hold in moisture in it.
I personally prefer EcoComplete, easy to use, no rinsing and the black color is great, especially with a black background. I have used Flourite many times in the past and HATE dealing with it, that's a lot of rinsing, rinsing and more rinsing, and it gets stuck under your fingernails!
Unfortunately no store nearby has any Flourite or Eco-complete.

I think that there's some pure latterite in that bin in the back. I'll run and check when the husband gets home
Oh Also, I have a hagen small pals pen (large) That I'm gonna put a Betta in along with an Anubais v. Barteri, I know they're low light plants, and the clip on light fixture uses your standard night light bulb...just wondering if this:
http://www.environmentallights.com/prod ... Cool_White Would output enough light for the plant to thrive? I don't like incandescent, And I have a heater in the tank anyway
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 8:28 pm
by Myaj
I have no idea how plants do with LED's
Re: Good substrate for growing plants???
Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 9:24 pm
by edmlfc1
I use Schultz aquatic soil from Home depot. Cheap and a little goes a long way.
