Page 1 of 1

How much salt do I add?

Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:48 am
by ILuvMyGSP
i have a 45 gal tank, how much salt, in cups, should i add each week to get it up to the right sg? i dont think i have enough in there right now and i dont want to overload it, i just have a the problem of measuring out how much to add. right now i have a floating hydrometer, and its not registering yet, its a few mm from the first line (my puffers are still young so its ok for a short time).. i got a small bag of marine salt and added 3/4 of it when i did a 50% water change last week, and last night i did another 25% water change because they tore up a mussel and made a huge cloudy mess, lol, and i added the last 1/4 of the package, but its still not salty enough. i dont know how much to add to get it to where it needs to be, or how much to add weekly so i dont crash it.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 9:41 pm
by Myaj
This is why you need a hydrometer that starts at zero or a refractometer.

I've typed out the way to figure salt measurments something like 5 times over the last week, and I'm not going to type it out again.

You can't go by measurement alone, because humidity and other factors change the moisture content in the salt, and how much you need to get the same salinity as a different sample of salt from different storage conditions.

But a rough guide is half a cup of marine salt will make one gallon of full marine. Do the math, and hope you don't go over by accident.

Or buy the right tools.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:39 am
by Pufferpunk
This is why you need a hydrometer that starts at zero or a refractometer.
Or buy the right tools.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:55 pm
by ILuvMyGSP
yes I have a hydrometer, not one of those 100 dollar things, but it tells salinity, I just wasnt sure how much to add during water changes to get the right amount, so I wouldnt go over.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 4:53 pm
by Myaj
Well, if you have a hyrdometer that tells you the salinity, what more do you need to know?

Add some salt to water, mix it up, and see where you are at. If you are too low, add more. If too high, dilute it with more water. That's the way I do it. After you've mixed it up a few times you know approx how much salt to add to how much water, but its still best to double check with a measuring device.

A hydrometer that reads down to 1.000 (freshwater) is only a few bucks, you just have to pay attention and make sure you buy one that doesn't start mid-brackish, sounds like you did that?. A refractometer generally runs in the $40-60 range, but are much quicker to use and more accurate, with less potential for misreads (due to needle sticking, air bubbles, or remaining salt from previous uses throwing off the readings).

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 5:31 pm
by Dadof4

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 6:32 pm
by ILuvMyGSP
Myaj wrote:Well, if you have a hyrdometer that tells you the salinity, what more do you need to know?

Add some salt to water, mix it up, and see where you are at. If you are too low, add more. If too high, dilute it with more water. That's the way I do it. After you've mixed it up a few times you know approx how much salt to add to how much water, but its still best to double check with a measuring device.

A hydrometer that reads down to 1.000 (freshwater) is only a few bucks, you just have to pay attention and make sure you buy one that doesn't start mid-brackish, sounds like you did that?. A refractometer generally runs in the $40-60 range, but are much quicker to use and more accurate, with less potential for misreads (due to needle sticking, air bubbles, or remaining salt from previous uses throwing off the readings).

oh oh ok ok, so i just add until its where it needs to be then? i was just so worried about messing it up and killing bacteria etc etc, i owned a puffer when i was a kid, it lived FOREVER until my heater broke and fried the poor thing without me knowing, and this time around i wanna do it right but ive never had a brackish tank before, so i just get a little nervous. thanks tho!

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:07 pm
by Myaj
Can you please slow down and explain what you are trying to do?

Yes, if your tank is established at one salinity and you suddenly change it, you will crash your biofilter. You can only change your salinity by .002 per week without damaging it.

If you are trying to mix up new water at a salinity that matches your current water, you mix it up until it reads the right level, using your hydrometer.

What salinity is your tank at now? What is your goal salinity? What fish do you have in there?

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:46 pm
by ILuvMyGSP
Myaj wrote:Can you please slow down and explain what you are trying to do?

Yes, if your tank is established at one salinity and you suddenly change it, you will crash your biofilter. You can only change your salinity by .002 per week without damaging it.

If you are trying to mix up new water at a salinity that matches your current water, you mix it up until it reads the right level, using your hydrometer.

What salinity is your tank at now? What is your goal salinity? What fish do you have in there?
ok.. i have a 45 gal tank with 2 GSP in there (im getting a 100 gal for my bday) i have a small bag of marine salt in there (the one pre measured for 5 gal of marine water) i also bought a new hydrometer, the one u fill up and the needles moves up to show the SG.. well i tested it a few times and it is not registering, so im assuming theres not enough salt in there to register yet, but i worry about adding too much at one time, and killing my good bacteria. i tested the salt in the pitcher before adding it and it was high sg, as high as it could go but after adding it to my tank during a water change, it didnt register anymore (obviously because it was diluted). im asking when i should add more, in a week? and how much i can add in cups at a time so i dont crash it. im basically starting from scratch, and am not sure how much to add each week.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 1:50 am
by Pufferpunk
For a rough estimate, it takes about 1 cup of salt/5g, to raise the SG .005. You'll have to do some math here, as you don't want to raise it more than .002. My guess would be close to around 2 cups of salt but you still need to check with a hydrometer. Maybe start with 1 cup & then check.

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 2:00 am
by Jase
Not sure if this thread needs to be kept cause the OP started a new one...

Re: How much salt do I add?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:27 am
by Pufferpunk
Agreed, I'll lock it for less confusion.