Page 1 of 1
Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2008 3:17 pm
by pinkfloydpuffer
As you can see from my sig, my 2 gsps are in a 20g right now. I'm working on getting my parents to allow me to get a 55g for my birthday (in about a month). My puffs are still pretty small right now (under 2"). My dad is a man of efficiency, and he doesn't think that 2 little fish need such a big tank. Could someone give me some very detailed reasons why they need such a big tank? Not like 'They'll be stunted", but more like some really scientific facts that I can throw at him (he is a mechanical engineer, he knows sciency stuff).
Getting this tank will mean throwing out my desk, lol, since I have no where else to put it. So any info that I can use to convince him would be really helpful. Thanks

Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2008 9:58 pm
by By_a_coo
I can ask him if he would feel comfortable in a bedroom for years with a small space to live! LOL
Sorry for joking. But the reason is very simple, you don't need any sciency stuff to prove your fish will need a larger tank to keep them healthy for years: the GSPs will grow and they will need more room for swimming, much more water to keep stable water parameters and much more space to keep them peaceful.
Hope that helps you in getting a bigger tank!
Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2008 10:47 pm
by Pufferpunk
Show him the pic of my adult 6" GSPs in my article in the library. Their mass takes in a lot of food, which means it poops out a lot of food too. Keeping the parameters pristene with all that eating & pooping going on, it will be difficult without the dilution of a much larger tank than they have now. Scientific enough?
Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2008 11:01 pm
by goby1kenobi
Fishbase article:
http://fishbase.com/Summary/speciesSumm ... groviridis
Simplistic, but if he wants hard numbers.... Note the line item that says "minimum aquarium size: 60 cm" (60cm = 23.65"). That's for the length of the tank. And that's for a single individual. You have two.
The other thing to consider is the rate of pollution of the tank in case of a power outage when you're on vacation. In a 20g tank, 100 grams of waste (just to pick a number) gives you ratio of 5 grams per gallon. In a 55g tank, that same 100 grams of waste gives you a ratio of 1.8 grams of waste per gallon. The 20g tank gets more than twice as dirty -- more than twice as deadly! -- as the 55g tank.
A large tank is much better at holding a steady temperature than a small tank, which is more easily prone to temperature swings. If the power goes out when it's cold, your fish have a much better chance of surviving in a large tank.
As far as efficiency... you get more efficiency from getting a 55g tank and its filters now than you do from purchasing first a 30g, then a 40g, and then a 55g as your fish outgrow the 20g...! It's also more efficient to get a large tank and do less frequent or smaller water changes than to use a small tank and do larger and more frequent water changes.
Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:28 am
by Agnate
Stunting IS a scientifically legitimate argument. Stunting involves the discontinued growth of the fish's body, while still allowing its organs to grow at their normal rate. This creates significant pressure on all of the organs, which inevitably results in the premature death of your fish due to organ failures.
Another thing you could do is ask around your neighbourhood for someone who has a puffer that's 6 inches or bigger, and ask if you can go take a visit. I guarantee that when he sees the girth of a 6 inch puffer, he'll understand why you need an upgrade. Pictures just don't do them justice, haha!
You can also use the argument that puffers are scaleless, meaning that they are incredibly susceptible to toxins (such as ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate, all of which are derived from their own biological waste). As Pufferpunk mentioned, without proper dilution (which is translated into a larger water volume), it would be nearly impossible to provide them with a good home. Since you enjoy your pets and take good care of them, it would be hypocritical to say that providing living standards that are blatantly inadequate for properly supporting your pet's life is adequate. It would be like comparing living underneath a desk is to living in an entire house; the desk is simply not adequate.
I'm going to guess your father hasn't really kept fish before. I think your best bet is to remind him that, although GSPs are slow growers, they will need approximately 30 gallons per puffer to live full and healthy lives (thriving, as opposed to surviving). Assuming you take good care of your fish (I'm sure you do), you should easily be able to say that you want to provide a home that will allow them the best life possible (much like your parents did for you), and your research has led you to requiring a tank of at least 60 gallons (which, by the way, a 55 gallon only actually holds 44 gallons of water BEFORE substrate/decorations, so a 55 gallon still won't technically be enough - however, you'll have a long time to upgrade the tank, as GSPs only grow about 1 inch per year, if not less). If he's still not willing to settle with a 55 gallon, see if you can barter getting a 40 or 50 gallon breeder (dimensions are 36 inches long by 18 inches wide for both breeders - just the height changes between them). In my opinion, they are much better than the standard 55 gallon tanks.

Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:03 pm
by pinkfloydpuffer
Thanks everyone
No, my dad hasn't kept fish. He's had a dog, but I'm really the animal person at home. If it was allowed I'd have snakes, lizards, hamsters, billions of fish, and so many more pets. But for now I'm limited to 3 tanks.
I'm thinking of getting this 55 I found (I wrote about it in another thread), but it's drilled and has a 33ish g sump, stand, and pump. All for $100. So I will take this info to him and hope that he will let me buy that tank. I did at least a month of hardcore research before I got my puffers, as they would be my first fish, and I wanted everything to go well. So I'm hoping that he will listen to what I say.
Re: Alright people, I need your help
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:12 pm
by CoreyK
Just tell him to watch them for 5 minutes and observe how active they are; then have him imagine them being nerf football sized. Hell, the tank will only be holding 15 gallons since there will be 5 gallons of fish in it