Page 1 of 2

So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Mon Dec 08, 2008 12:42 pm
by flash.dan
My partner although says she doesnt like the fish secretly does. (( appart from the arro- its scary apparently?? ))

anyway over the last year shes been fantastic feedign them when im at work turning there lights on + off mornigns and evenings etc........ saturday she saw some some different puffers instead of mbus HA! she adores GSP's and stars and stripes puffers. even to the point where she asked if we could get some Gsps for our living room tank 6x2 with cutiepie.... she didnt believe me that she would probably kill other puffers and believes that because shes friendly with community fish shell be fine.... .anyway.....

I have a 4x2 in my wardrobe t5's fluval fx5 etc.... Had it as a hospital tank but never had the need for it..... who thinks it would be a good idea to supprise her with a pair of puffers as her tank for crimbo? i think i can probably get away with saying the acaras are sick and that i need to get the tank setup for them. as she loves those guys she wont ask questions and she has no idea about cycling etc.

really need womens POV here if this is a good idea. Ill be stuck with one more tank to clean but.... hope she will like it and stuck for ideas... drawing on the title she doesnt want her own tank but wants GSPs which arnt possible with 2x mbus or a arro..... so goes wanting GSPs mean she wants her own tank? as ive found with expierence reading between the lines with women is very very dangerous hahahaha

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Mon Dec 08, 2008 5:44 pm
by indie
hmm.. I'd say if shes asked for them in the living room, then your good to go with getting them for her for a xmas pressie :D
It'll be a nice suprise for her :D

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Mon Dec 08, 2008 7:48 pm
by edmlfc1
I second that. :D

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 2:43 am
by Idontknow
Nice idea!

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 5:04 am
by flash.dan
I hinted last night she isnt too keane i think..... She had the idea of putting 2-3 gsps in with cutie pie. Shes still adament that because shes in with tetras acaras fire eels barbs and plecs shell be fine with other puffers too.....

She really wants some mind so i may go out on a limb! but i have a feeling she wont be as pleased as i will for a 4th tank. All be it about 700L smaller than any of my others.......

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 2:12 pm
by Jase
You should tell her that's the only way, because the GSPs need salty water...

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 3:16 pm
by Myaj
Yes, the GSP's can't go in freshwater (and would probably nip Cutie Pie to death on top of it).

I don't know what to tell you.. if she doesn't want another tank set up (is your place crowded?), I wouldn't. But if she really likes them, and wouldn't mind another huge tank taking up room, then I would...

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 8:41 pm
by groovitudedude
I'd start her off on like a 20 or 40G just so she gets a better hang of being almost completely responsible for fish. Teach her the ropes, it should be fun :)

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2008 10:32 pm
by marksrush
flash.dan wrote:My partner although says she doesnt like the fish secretly does.
Same with my partner. It was always, "You spend too much money on these darn fish!" or "You're crazy for buying another aquarium!" But now the other night he told me he wouldn't mind having a tank for his room, which about floored me. And I of course will be happy to grant him his wish. :)

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 4:34 am
by flash.dan
Myaj wrote:Yes, the GSP's can't go in freshwater (and would probably nip Cutie Pie to death on top of it).

I don't know what to tell you.. if she doesn't want another tank set up (is your place crowded?), I wouldn't. But if she really likes them, and wouldn't mind another huge tank taking up room, then I would...

well ive decided.... She can have a 120L with a few gsps and ill get a similar one with a arrow for crimbo i think!

I wouldnt be worried about cutie pie she has a bad habbit of biting back i have a 14" plec with her and almost every time he bumps her she will chase after him! there was a rip in his fin a few weeks back and i have a funny feeling it was her

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 7:52 am
by t1gerbee
you did pick up on the whole.... needs salt... high brackish as they grow bit ... right?

If she wants some cute puffers, maybe fig 8's are better, require a lot lower salt long term and are therefore easier to maintain.

You buy her a cute fish that will need high end brackish to full marine by 3 inches and she may not be impressed. High salt means epensive salt, means water changes involving mixing in the salt first and letting it mature... also means no real plants etc...

you could get fig 8's instead, just as cute, stay smaller, so more in a 120L tank.. and only need a little salt, so easier on the wallet, and easier to maintain...


better option all round i think. :-)

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 12:57 pm
by flash.dan
oh no she wont maintain them haha.... shell feed and love them!

Im afraid i get stuck with the menial jobs + bills!

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 1:28 pm
by Myaj
How many gallons is 120L? That's only about 40 gallons, correct? So only one GSP in that tank I'm afraid..

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 3:55 pm
by flash.dan
wellits a 3x1 so i think 2 gsps for her

Re: So my partner wants her own tank!

Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2008 4:11 pm
by Agnate
120L ~= 30 gallons, if I'm not mistaken. You really don't want to put two full-grown GSPs in a 30 gallon tank. If this is going to be the permanent tank for the GSP(s), I'd seriously stick to 1 GSP. You can easily put 2-3 Figure 8s in that tank, though. :)