Page 3 of 3

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2010 7:20 am
by bibbles
Okay, so, I've been planning on getting everything online, but yesterday I went by a pet shop cause i was in the area, and I like to get a feel for prices, cause sometimes you need something now, not after shipping. I asked what they charged for the GLO lights, and they didn't have the one I asked for, but offered the display 48" WITH lamps for $90 with all the everything that comes with it. Game on, looked around a little more and found a 20g kit for only $2 more than a 12g kit I was gonna buy online. Bought it, got snails and some moss...

I was going to wait till I got a substrate to set it up, but I was drunk last night, haha, and went to school (couple blocks) and acquired some gravel and stones and sticks, and set up the tank. Added the snails and moss and everything, then today bought a couple plants and 2/2 fancy guppies male/female - cherry shrimp on Thursday. It's just my feeder tank, for snails and shrimp, but I figured, since it's a 20g I should add some fish, thus the guppies.

It's got a not so amazing, but sufficient light, and though it's a hang on back filter makes no noise (bottom of outlet touches water level, and the air filter makes more noise anyway). I've got like 20+ snails, ramshorn, and some really long spirally ones, as well as a few random others. The filter was broken when I first got it, but I went back by the place and he didn't even ask to check it, just gave me a new filter right away. They even keep GSPs in brackish water! I like this place very much, and it's nice to say hi to the Comoto Dragon and other stuff when I stopped by.

I've never asked for snails anywhere else before, but instead of just grabbing the ones off the sides, the guy actually searched through the plants and everything for all of them, and when my girlfriend picked out a plant to buy me, the guy said not to get it cause one leaf was a little damaged, and said she could have any other plant for 50% off cause she couldn't get the one she wanted. I've not done a lot of fish stuff in the past, but it seemed like a very nice place!

I got the guppies at a different place that wouldn't believe that F8s and GSPs were different puffers, and have them all in one FW tank, but the guppies were cheap, and plentiful, and they're just guppies, and the fish, for the most part, looked very healthy... and that was my day, haha. The tank came with some Nutrafin de-chlorinator and bacteria stuff... I was skeptical, but as it was just snails at first I was like whatever, I added the fish and they seem to be doing great, playing hide and seek, chasing and playing with the few bits of plants that floated away on the current, and poking at the snails from time to time.

I'm very happy with the set up, I almost got DPs, but I wanted Amazon Puffers in the big tank, and the snails are to feed them, and the DPs will probably ruinate the snails which I wanna feed them, and the cherry shrimp offspring as well. And I'm kinda excited for guppy fry, there are lots of hiding places so they should survive, though I still feel like I should have gotten a breeder tank, though I wasn't planning on it at the time... yeah, anyway, that's enough for tonight, lol.

EDIT: Oh yeah, of the 4 guppies, my favorite, the most colorful one with sexy fins, isn't really eating, he sometimes grabs a bit of the Nutrifin flakes, but doesn't seem to eat them, just take a bite and move on, while the others will greedily eat whole giant flakes and fight over them... the internet said that those flakes should be good for guppies, maybe he's just a little stressed... The ones I picked in the tank at the store were the most devious when it came to avoiding the net, most of the others didn't much care even, haha. So yeah, if anyone has any ideas, I know it's not a puffer but, ya know...

EDIT2: Oh yeah, one of the snails, I think it's a tiny Japanese snail, and he's always moving everywhere, fast, like he's on a mission, I named him Rambo, the puffies will not get to eat him. :D

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2010 6:56 pm
by bazil323
LilGreenPuffer wrote:
bazil323 wrote:Most puffers can get by with a good diet of crunchy, meaty foods for them to grind down their teeth. However, SAPs will need regular teeth trimming even with a good diet.

GSPs start out in fresh/light brackish water as fry and then gradually move into full saltwater as adults. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about that. However, there is some confusion regarding figure 8 puffers. Most people keep them in light brackish water because they are much healthier and live longer with these conditions because they must have very hard water with a high pH. For this reason, some people have kept figure 8s in very hard freshwater, but it's more feasible for most people to just add some marine salt to the water and use crushed coral or aragonite to raise the hardness.
Actually, RTR did a study and found out that F8s in FW don't live as long and tend to be sicklier, even with a high pH.
Oh really? I didn't see that. Thanks for letting me know; I'll stop spreading the myth then. Is it posted in a thread or article? I'd like to read it and bookmark it for future use.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:10 am
by Nick
Yes - from what I've heard him say, my interpretation is that the carbonates and alkalinity of the water are what benefit F8's; the actual sodium chloride in the sea salt mix is probably neutral in effect and may at best be an agonist agent for the much more important compounds, helping them do what they do but doing nothing on it's own.