Page 3 of 4
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 2:03 pm
by Dadof4
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 2:15 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
omplmpa3 wrote:I wish I had payed more attention during biology and chemistry classes in high school, darn you William Shakespeare!
Never!
SHAKESPEARE LIVES!!!
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 8:04 pm
by Jagatorjake
Jagatorjake wrote:I've had a diatom problem for a while now. has anyone had any experience with poly pads? i've heard that its a type of filter media that takes nutrients out of the water to essentially starve the algae.
Anyone??? haha
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 8:34 pm
by Dadof4
For algae these may work but for diatoms I don't think that they would work. They remove some of the organic compounds that cause diatoms but the main, silica, isn't removed by these. I know there are substances like ChemiPure Elite that will remove the silicate from the water but, honestly, that's not addressing the root cause.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 8:41 pm
by omplmpa3
LilGreenPuffer wrote:omplmpa3 wrote:I wish I had payed more attention during biology and chemistry classes in high school, darn you William Shakespeare!
Never!
SHAKESPEARE LIVES!!!
Yeah, I didn't mean it. I will always take literature over the sciences, especially Shakespeare. Henry V,
I named my SAP after Christopher Marlowe.
Jagatorjake wrote:I've had a diatom problem for a while now. has anyone had any experience with poly pads? i've heard that its a type of filter media that takes nutrients out of the water to essentially starve the algae.
I've just concluded that I've got diatoms, so I have yet to try anything. I need to do some research first. One piece of information that I do keep coming across is that some silicate removing products will also remove phosphates. So if you have a planted tank you will have to replenish the phosphate level to maintain plant health.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 9:25 pm
by Jagatorjake
ya, i'm not using chemicals on algae at all. i guess i just assumed algae and diatoms required the same things for survival, and after reading about diatoms figured that filter media may work. also i don't think the plants in my tank would be affected by it as long as there is still light and CO2. then again, i could be totally wrong on that matter. is there a way to check for silicate or phosphate levels in the tank?
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 10:00 pm
by Dadof4
Yes you can test for them but the kits are kind of expensive
http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/p ... atid=16552
I'm sure there are other out there that may be cheaper but this is the only one I really find when I look. Meh, my wife thinks my pockets are gold lined so why not the pet shops?

Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 10:39 pm
by omplmpa3
Jagatorjake wrote:is there a way to check for silicate or phosphate levels in the tank?
Your local LFS may be able to test for them, I've had mine test for phosphates before.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 10:48 am
by Iliveinazoo
Jagatorjake wrote:ya, i'm not using chemicals on algae at all. i guess i just assumed algae and diatoms required the same things for survival, and after reading about diatoms figured that filter media may work. also i don't think the plants in my tank would be affected by it as long as there is still light and CO2. then again, i could be totally wrong on that matter. is there a way to check for silicate or phosphate levels in the tank?
Phosphate is one of the most important nutrients that a plant requires.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2009 3:39 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Well now I'm confused. I have one tank, out of my 18, that's got this coating on my plants, looks like rust -- is that diatoms? Strange thing is that this is one of the tanks I don't have a sand substrate in, it's got gravel. First I had a problem with this slick black stuff, that came off easily enough when you would rub it, it would fall off in like "sheets". I got an algae eater and that fish loved that stuff, kept it off everything, but then my Abei was moved into that tank, and he killed the algae eater. Now I still have a little of the black stuff, but I've noticed that some of my plants have that brownish-rusty like stuff on their leaves. I can rub it off, but it won't come off completely, in fact, it seems that if I don't try and get it off immediately that it just won't rub off, but if it's not been there long, then it will rub off. I can't put any other algae eaters in that tank because Hymie (the Abei) would kill them, I'm sure.
So what does one do with this stuff? If I don't have a sandy substrate .... what has caused this to happen? This isn't a new tank, and it was doing really well when I had the CO2 going into it, but seems like when I stopped the CO2 that's when I started having problems with algae and this rusty-coloured stuff.
Any comments, anyone?

Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2009 3:57 pm
by pufferfreak
The stuff the fuels diatom growth can come in with water changes (your water has all those minerals probably) so you might try using that bottled distilled water at the grocery store for water changes. Or getting and RO/DI unit.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2009 4:57 pm
by pufferpuggirl
What about using something that removes Phosphates and Silicates, will that help? I can't spend the money on distilled water, this is England -- everything is expensive!

Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2009 7:56 pm
by omplmpa3
The brown rusty looking stuff probably is diatoms. I think if your were to start up with the CO2 again that would take care of it. You could also try increasing the lighting. Flourish Excel may work, it has carbon. I'm trying to think back and I'm quite sure my plants did better and the diatoms were less noticeable when I used Excel.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2009 9:42 pm
by pufferfreak
Or just by plants that get to the nutrients before the diatoms can.
Re: Question about diatoms or brown algae
Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2009 6:26 am
by pufferpuggirl
I actually do have some Excel in my refrigerator, never got around to using it as I had intended. I will give it a try and see what happens. Thanks so much for your comments and suggestions.
