Page 2 of 3
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 10:29 pm
by StriGoi
All the different jargon... LoL...
Guys any pics to share?
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 6:55 am
by Nick
I try to run with multiple pumps or filters whenever possible. I started because the secondary or tertiary filters are a great way to instantly cycle a quarantine tank.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 7:17 am
by StriGoi
Nick wrote:I try to run with multiple pumps or filters whenever possible. I started because the secondary or tertiary filters are a great way to instantly cycle a quarantine tank.
In this case wouldn't there be much heat generated?
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 7:19 am
by Nick
I have never found filters to produce enough heat to matter. Heat generated by filters is "free" in reality, because it will allow the heaters in the tanks to turn on less often.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 7:28 am
by StriGoi
Nick wrote:I have never found filters to produce enough heat to matter. Heat generated by filters is "free" in reality, because it will allow the heaters in the tanks to turn on less often.
oh, i forgot one fact is that ur living in the states. LOL....
In singapore where i work, damn the temperature can reach up till 32degress ...
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 4:49 pm
by Flutter
Up to 32C
It was at least 37 today up in the cold white north

Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 10:24 pm
by StriGoi
Flutter wrote:Up to 32C
It was at least 37 today up in the cold white north

Over here is Degrees Celsius not Fahrenheit.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 11:25 pm
by Myaj
She knows, she was just giving you a hard time.
Extra filters will add extra heat, no matter if they are internal, external, hang on back or cannister. The water has to pass through the motor one way or the other. About the only way you can avoid that is by using an air driven (very weak) filter or if you just want water movement, they now make powerheads that attach to the side of the tank magnetically, with the motor outside of the tank.
Keeping tank temps low is not fun.. its the reason I've never been able to have my dream tank.. seahorses.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2010 2:16 am
by StriGoi
Myaj wrote:She knows, she was just giving you a hard time.
Extra filters will add extra heat, no matter if they are internal, external, hang on back or cannister. The water has to pass through the motor one way or the other. About the only way you can avoid that is by using an air driven (very weak) filter or if you just want water movement, they now make powerheads that attach to the side of the tank magnetically, with the motor outside of the tank.
Keeping tank temps low is not fun.. its the reason I've never been able to have my dream tank.. seahorses.
LoL... I noticed.... Everyone here is mostly from the states or canada AND mostly are "she".... LOL
Anyways, you could add a chiller for you seahorses.
I was at a pet farm just now and i saw a box puffer!!! OMG, they are like so adorable!!!! LOL
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2010 6:41 pm
by Flutter
Err. I missed the second C. Notice how the first one was 32C?

It's hotter in Canada than it is in Singapore

Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2010 11:06 pm
by StriGoi
Flutter wrote:Err. I missed the second C. Notice how the first one was 32C?

It's hotter in Canada than it is in Singapore

In ontario it get up to -30c during winter and climbing.
BTW, do you add in a "heater" when ur fishes are sick?
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Fri Jun 25, 2010 8:01 am
by Flutter
I think it was 2 years ago that we had a month that was -40C. It was so cold. That's in the south end of the country too, I'm not sure I could handle going up north in the winter.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Sat Jun 26, 2010 5:39 pm
by LD50
Unless you have a species that is sensitive to how much flow you have (discus come to mind) I see no downside to having 2x filtration units. The heat generated in a canister is very small, odds are your lights heat your tank way more than a filter. As for HOB’s any heat generated by an HOB will readily dissipate due to the high level of surface agitation. Another way you could add extra filtration while helping cool your tank and using very little electricity would be to ad a sponge filter, which may take a little creativity to hide but they are definitely tried and true forms of extra filtration.
Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Sat Jun 26, 2010 8:14 pm
by Flutter
LD50, I like your name!

Re: Dual External Filter - Pros & Cons -
Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:11 pm
by RTR
I only use heaters in in water aging vessels. The lights and multi-filtering provide the heat needed. We do have the house HVAC operating 24/7 so there is very little seasonal variation in indoor temperatures. But the tanks outside the tank room are heated more by the lighting than by the filters - the filters are all high-efficiency units, and the tank room lights are all suspended above the tanks to reduce tank heating from them, although they do keep the area warm overall rather than locally.