Page 2 of 3

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 4:54 pm
by Pufferpunk
Can you describe in detail how you cycled it & what you have your tank stocked with now? Did you keep track of parameters?

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 5:06 pm
by Nick
RTR, I PM'd you so as not to derail the thread.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 2:32 pm
by Brandon8521
ammonia source- 3 adult platties (with about 10 fry under 1/2 inch), 2 guppies, and 1 ballon mollie

26th of feb- applied the nite-out to my tank. parameters were amm .25, nitrites 0, and nitrates 0.
27th - morning(amm closer to .5, nitrite and nitrate were 0)
b4 bed (amm back down closer to .25, nitrite 0, nitrate still unreadable)

Up untill yesterday i had kept a slight ammonia reading and more and more nitrate but never any nitrite. So yesterday my final water parameter test was amm 0, nitrite 0, nitrate around 10-15 ppm. I did a water change last night to lower the nitrates and now im back on my old weekly water change schedule.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:02 pm
by Pufferpunk
So you only added the product 1x? How did you know how much to use? Let us know if the ammonia/nitrite stay the same w/o adding any more product.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu Mar 04, 2010 3:33 am
by Brandon8521
Yah I only gave it one dose, actually about 3 doses at once. It was 1 tbls per 10 gallons. But I added 3 per. Since it's live bacteria I didn't think it would hurt. I have read you can't really overdose with live bacteria but I will definitaly keep this thread updated until I think my tank is completely stable.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 10:42 pm
by Kungpaoshizi
I had great success with Nite Out II...
Btw, says right on the bottle for those saying it's not the right bacteria...

Bacterial additive with select strains of nitrosomonas, nitrobacter, and nitrospira

I think BioSpira has some legitimate competition besides the fact Spira contains the coccus..
So the only difference with TRUE SW bacteria would be the coccus strain?

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 11:20 pm
by Brandon8521
Im glad to see someone else has used this stuff it has worked for me and i see you aswell.... could you give some detail as to what type of tank you used it in and if you can remember what kind of results you had (time period and such.) I aswell think that this stuff will gain fans as people learn what it is and give a shot. Also when you baught it was it refrigerated or stocked on the shelfs? By the way as a update my tank is still doing what its doing and without my puffer in the tank :( i am down to biweekly water changes :D .

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 12:31 am
by Kungpaoshizi
Uhh, at the time, it was not in the fridge, but the store is about 65 degrees, so prolly about 60 in the bottle, sg was 1.005 maybe?
I just used the instructions on it, but the extra 50% per dose, used flake food for ammonia source, was a week? maybe 1.2? then all was good..

Forgot to mention above, it's "<bacteria name> sp." and like I stated, I think the only diff between FW and SW is the coccus strain?

I can't member, google the name + the sp. and you'll find a ton of info... The bottle is sealed, after trying that and bio spira(and it failed), i'll have to go with the nite out ii again...
But still, who knows, could totally be handling of product that make the diff /shrug

Might be new, but science is advancing all the time, and since it's the acutal bacteria that is in the end result NATURALLY, I don't see why not.
Perhaps a different "strain" but I mean, take the pig flu, or MRSA... They're the SAME as the other stuff, but just a different strain, and they're way badass compared to the "until now" recognized and common virus/bacteria....

I mean cmon, there's stuff STILL being discovered on Earth? heh, we can't say we know it all /shrug

Anyway you look at it, you have a 50/50 chance :)
I'll take that chance with a 12$ product rather than a 30$ product.

And yes, after a crap ton of reading and looking at ingredients, nite out ii, and spira are the only 2 I think that CLEARLY state ingredients and ARE the end result bacteria.

Except BioZyme, that worked on a smaller tank for me, was within a week or so, but it's totally different bacteria based on completely different science. But I think it actually colonized whatever type of bacteria that was, uhh, hetrophic bacteria/enzymes...
I *think* anyways, didn't have the tank up long term.. So i guess reading up on actual life cycle of the hetrophic bacteria would be wise, it uses beta oxidation and not dissolved oxygen too, so whether or not it colonizes long term, it's still not a combatant with the true bacteria..

Actually ya, I'll read up on that tomorrow and write some more...(big fan of science)
Let alone 2 living bacteria is better than 1 right? heh (well, dissolved oxygen consuming AND the beta oxidation type)
I guess unless it creates some abnormal condition long term that would perhaps give the fish tumors or something... Or makes them crawl out of the tank and start breathing air!
Ok maybe not...

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 1:03 am
by Kungpaoshizi
Ya here was some of the interesting stuff I found on it:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_o ... fced6224a3

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_o ... 0be89f51f7

Ha, and ya, this might explain why it worked super well especially cause I used the last teaspoon or so of my biozyme over a period of about 3-4 days... Perhaps that could have made up for the lack of refridgeration?
http://www.jstor.org/pss/4250625

Ya, read the concluding remarks on page 175:
"We can no longer consider N. europaea to be the dominant or even a typical ammonia oxidizer.Other species and strains are important in a range of environments, and physiological differences leading to dominance of these strains require investigation........... Many aspects of basic biochemistry are poorly understood. Little is known of the methods of transport of the substrate into the cell, despite their potential importance in determining saturation constants for growth and activity."

--Advances in Microbial Physiology By Anthony H. Rose
copyright 1989~

So if that's theorizing in such an in-depth area of science, perhaps they would have just started to produce viable solutions in a bottle...

Anyone know off hand when Bio Spira came out? I wonder if his "magical formula" is based on previous science...

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Wed May 12, 2010 4:02 pm
by briguy44
I just read this thread and decided to cycle my new 55 gallon tank with nite-out II. I got it at petco and it was unrefrigerated. Just set up the tank last night and added the stuff this morning. My sg is at 1.002. I decided to start out cycling it with low sg because it sounds like it works much better for FW. I plan on bringing up the sg slowly to where i want it after everything is strong and stable. Right now my ammonia is 0, nitrite 0, and nitrate 5 ppm. I will keep you posted on how things work out for me. I am a little worried since the stuff was unrefrigerated but I guess we'll see what happens. :thumb:

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Wed May 12, 2010 6:28 pm
by Brandon8521
What are you useing as an amonia source?

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu May 13, 2010 12:04 am
by briguy44
I have two mollies in there along with some ghost shrimp.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu May 13, 2010 12:17 am
by Brandon8521
I suggest doing a fishless cycle just throw a peice of raw shrimp in there to give the tank ammonia or go to homedepot and buy pure amonia. Its really hard on the fish to go through all of the ammonia levels and nitrite levels. Even hardy fish like mollies will start to loose scales cause of constantly rubbing on stuff because there skin burns not to mention the gills and insides are being burnt aswell. Its just not pleasent for anything alive.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu May 13, 2010 1:12 am
by briguy44
ehh, didn't you use fish to cycle your tank with when you used this stuff??????

My live bearing feeder fish 2 guppies, 1 ballon mollie(just for looks), 1 male platty, and 2 female platty(along with some fry but none are larger then 1/2 inch( I feed the fry to my chiclids.)) I dont like to keep this cycle going with my remining fish in there but so far all there appetites are still up and and even the latest batch of fry are doing fine. One of my female platty is about to give birth aswell. I am also aware that most platty dont like a sg of above 1.005 but i have read into it and by trying it out some will actually do very well in it. The central american breeds tend not to but the south eastern united states breed actually like it. i have done this sg chance with alot of care and made sure that my platty have kept breeding through out my salinity levels. So far so good and this is as far as i plan on going with my sg. It's usually around 1.014, but decided to raise it a notch to see if they would breed at this level.

Re: Any results with Microbe-Lift products?

Posted: Thu May 13, 2010 1:48 am
by Brandon8521
I didn't have a choice when I used it it was for an emergency cycle my system crashed. If I had the choice I wouldn't have had any fish in there.