Page 2 of 2

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:41 pm
by Kungpaoshizi
I dunno, I've been reading like crazy all over the net, and there seems to be quite a few people who are very nice and understanding towards people new to aquariums and such, but wow, I must just post the wrong dam stuff lol!

I do find though if someone brings the truth out about a certain aspect of a product, especially one intended for nitrite/nitrate removal it brings out the flamers and trolls.

I mean really, if it were a perfect world, and everyone knew about cycling and the 20 bazillion other "proper" methods of keeping fish from day 1, what would be the point of the products?
But if you use them, and TELL someone! Oh lookout! lol

It's quite discouraging...

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 9:09 pm
by Flutter
Well, I don't know what to say but my best guess would be that a lot of people look to use such products as a quick fix instead of doing something like water changes that will repair a problem instead of cover it up.

Perhaps that misuse has created an immediate negative bias.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Wed Mar 10, 2010 11:35 am
by RTR
I've read the label,and the site as well, and I do understand the terminology.. FYI,"detoxify" does not mean or even imply "remove" it means only "render non-toxic. Detoxifying dissolved ammonia gas, dissolved chlorine gas, nitrite ion, etc. does not "remove" those materials from the tank at all. The detoxification involves only a change to a nontoxic form, period. I do also understand that if the tank is not cycled and well maintained, those materials may, and in several of those cases, will be back.

Any hobby or other practice involving chemistry and biochemistry, biology, physiology, and physics does have a specialized language. If you do not understand the language, you will not be able to understand what people are saying to you, or even what labels are saying and equally important, not saying.

If you do not understand the terminology, ask what it means. You will get answers and perhaps gain some information. If you do not ask, you are all too likely to jump to unjustified conclusions assume them to be fact. When you present those as fact, you are equally likely to be corrected. That too is a learning process if you accept it.

Lesson: "Conditioners" in the aquarium hobby are primarily treatments used to detoxify utility-added disinfectants from piped potable water supplies. They may also, largely as a matter of "branding" (= approximately, distinguishing one product from another) offer certain other supposed advantages such as theoretical slime coat treatments , etc.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 1:40 am
by Kungpaoshizi
Dude, just stop responding, again, you are totally missing the point of my post.

The company says "we don't really know why it does that" and "it takes an overdose according to the responses we have received".

Anything like that on the market would be banned until review was done and figured out by the FDA if it was a med.

Again, I do understand the terminology, and that was not my point. Perhaps you need a dictionary to understand what "we don't know" and "false advertising" means.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 1:54 am
by Pufferpunk
I think this thread is really going nowhere but getting argumentative, at this point.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 4:27 am
by Nick
The FDA is a corrupt institution at its core. They allow a drug company to do as many studies as it wishes, yet when they send a drug for approval, they can cherry-pick which studies are included. The result? Many drugs, particularly antidepressants and other "happy pills" are approved when if you include all the actual research, they don't work any better than sugar pills, and have increased rates of suicide and other negative behaviors across all studies. Do they help a FEW people? Yes, probably. But they also carry as much risk as reward, and honestly do absolutely nothing, positive or negative, for 4/5 of the people who take them. They are, however a multi-billion dollar industry, even prescribed by GPs.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime

Posted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 3:21 pm
by Myaj
The idea behind Prime and Amquel is pretty simple.

They do not REMOVE things like ammonia or nitrite, they just help you get through the tough part of a cycle. They are still there, so the bacteria can still use them and complete the cycle. Once the tank is cycled, the ammonia and nitrite are no longer a problem, and you are just using the product for its original intent, dechlor.

There are products out there that do physically remove ammonia or nitrites.. and they DO cause problems when you stop using them, as they prevented the bacteria from ever being established. We generally only recommend those in a major emergency, and only for temporary use (a day or two).

Anyone who asks about a basic new tank startup is very likely to be given this info.. Amquel or Prime will HELP with the process, if the person has already tossed some fish into an uncycled tank. They won't solve the problem, but they help a lot. Good for Amquel and Prime!

Yes, people get a little impatient.. but think of it this way.. the "newbs" with their crashing/cycling tanks could have easily avoided the problem if they'd taken some time to research the care of their animals before they bought them! And online forums with large traffic like this one see this same thing repeated every single day! It gets old, it gets frustrating, it is disgusting how many live animals are killed each day because new owners don't do their research or the salespeople at the store tell them the wrong info.

And don't even get me started on the companies and their sales pitches.. I was at a local store one day when a big name company was in giving "training" to 10 new employees. I lingered around to hear the "training".. not a word about the chemistry or how it works or what the fish need, it was all about "you are required to suggest this or that product at all times.. we have secret shoppers and if you don't, your pay will be docked". Now that is sick, but its marketing. In the end, it all comes down to the person who decides they will be responsible for the keep and health of another living being doing what they can to make that life good, and make the right choices.