Page 2 of 5
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:47 pm
by J-P
or a wife that is willing to participate
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:50 pm
by busybones
They are pretty handy lol
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:24 am
by LilGreenPuffer
Hey, what am I talking about? I have J-P! How are those South American adoptions coming, honeybunches?
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:45 am
by J-P
sorry hun, we're not ready yet. I don't think their rooms will be ready until at least mid Feb. Lots of remodeling and decoration to do.
but that is a little off topic
edit .. just fixed some spelling mistakes
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:55 am
by Pufferpunk
Hubby's really handy for plumbing the tanks--he's a 40 year pipefitter. He is a gem when I'm recovering from surgery or illness but otherwise, he won't touch the tanks. I'm lucky he feeds the dog when I'm not around... At least he puts up with me!
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 3:23 am
by LilGreenPuffer
That's all you can ask, I guess - take me as I am!
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 10:57 am
by RTR
Yes, the Ammonia Alert detects free ammonia only, the bad stuff. What I don't know is how long the Ammonia Alert lasts. And also yes, the test kit you ref'd is the correct one - plus the customer comment is right on - it is the most user-UNfriendly test That I own. It is a PITA, but it gives good results.
+1 to all who said that the chloramines/ammonia must be treated before the water goes into the tank. Someone said that it dissipates within 24 hours - very poor advice IMHO. I do not want my fish stressed or injured by free ammonia at all, and under no circumstances for 24 hours. I would quit keeping fish first... If I cannot do it right, I will not do it at all.
When using Prime, if you cannot pre-treat the water BEFORE it goes into the tank, you should add Prime dosage for the whole capacity of the tank, not just the quantity actually used. If you can pre-treat the water, just use the dosage for the actual volume to be treated. This is a situation where concentrations do matter.
I am a husband, but I do not carry water routinely. I discovered pumps and tubing some time ago. They work wonders.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:41 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
RTR wrote:+1 to all who said that the chloramines/ammonia must be treated before the water goes into the tank. Someone said that it dissipates within 24 hours - very poor advice IMHO. I do not want my fish stressed or injured by free ammonia at all, and under no circumstances for 24 hours. I would quit keeping fish first... If I cannot do it right, I will not do it at all.
You misunderstood. I always detoxify the ammonia from my tap water with Prime. The excess ammoniUM is processed by the biofilter. Sorry, I should have been clearer!
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 2:17 pm
by Pufferpunk
RTR wrote:When using Prime, if you cannot pre-treat the water BEFORE it goes into the tank, you should add Prime dosage for the whole capacity of the tank, not just the quantity actually used. If you can pre-treat the water, just use the dosage for the actual volume to be treated. This is a situation where concentrations do matter.
I discovered pumps and tubing some time ago. They work wonders.

This is also how I do things around here. I dose enough Prime for the entire system directly into the tank & fill from the tap. I buy the large pond-sized Prime.
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 8:54 pm
by RTR
Prime and Excel I get in larger sizes also - much cheaper, and put it in smaller bottles for use. There are some economies to running too many tanks.
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 3:24 am
by kilofey
thanks guys, very helpful.... however, i really like to run the water straight from the tap and into the tank to avoid those cumbersome 5 gal buckets, im fairly weak in the muscles department

and my boyfriend wants nothing to do with water changes so he wont carry them for me he says, well you shouldnt have such big tanks, then you wouldnt need to carry those big buckets! GRR... anyway, so since i put the water directly into the tank... at the right temp of course, how do i calculate the ACTUAL gallons of water in my tank? do you have to figure out how much gravel you have and subtract it or something? and how do i do that??? are you guys shure this prime stuff is really that awesome? it seems like mroe of a headache than anything. now i have to buy an ungodly complicated ammonia test kit for it.... and i have to figure out the proper ammount of prime to add to my 55 gal and i have no idea where to start with gravel volume .....sheesh, is there some other compareable product that might be less complicated? perhaps one where i can still use my API liquid test kit? i know its making the ammonia non toxic, im just afriad ill end up overdosing the tank somehow... since i only need one capfull for my entire 55 gal... and then having to take into account the ammount of gravel and water displacement.... just seems like it could get over/under dosed really easily... seems like just a matter of getting it just a hair too full/less would be bad.... i dont know.... and then what about when i do the 25% weekly WC, you said to dose the whole tank right? what about the other 75% of old water that is getting dosed again? does this stuff build up? will i eventually accumulate WWWAAYY too much in the tank?
sorry about all the questions.... this prime stuff is just starting to confuse me
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 3:50 am
by LilGreenPuffer
You really don't need another test kit. Just dose the Prime and rest assured that the ammonia in your tank is now non-toxic.
Don't get too anxious about getting the dose exactly right, either. An estimation is really good enough.
About the buildup - don't worry! It's been working for these folks for decades. Sometimes you just have to trust that they know what they're doing.
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 7:17 am
by pufferpuggirl
busybones wrote:LilGreenPuffer wrote:Geeeeez, you use a 5g bucket for all those tanks? If I were you, I'd have gotten some really big trash cans or something by now. How long do water changes take you?
It isn't that bad (my hubby helps

) On a 55 gallon tank it usually takes about 15-20 minutes. But I try to do them on separate days. I would use big trash cans but don't want them setting around the house. The extra work doesn't really bother me

I'm very much like you Busy ... Only I don't have a 5-gallon bucket, only a 3-gallon, but what I do is pour the water into big plastic containers, then treat that water with Prime and then add to tank. It's bad enough that I have like 3 largish plastic containers hanging around the house, so I can't even possibly think of having any big trash cans in here -- plus over here, it's hard to find inexpensive plastic trash cans like you can at Home Depot, etc. Just a little container can be expensive, so I make do with what's available.
Hey, has anyone used the powder superconcentrate version of Prime yet? I was thinking about getting it, but on 2nd thought decided that I didn't want to deal with anything that I'd have to mix up, but I'd love to hear from anyone that's actually used the new concentrate.
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 8:22 am
by soggydrysuit
I'm still using the puffers old
tank for my water changes!
Just because I'm doing two 50% changes per week to lessen the impact of the gradual salinity increase I'm doing for the Celons. I can add salt and conditioner and leave under heat and aeration for 24 hrs. Transfer by small pond pump...
They're also probably the messiest fish I have ever kept

Fed them some small crabs yesterday plus some snails which were simply demolished.
Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 10:32 am
by RTR
Under My 55 is a 33 XL (same footprint, much less tall) on th same stand. That smaller tank is my water change reservoir for the 55. The 33XL is refilled after each water change, treated with Prime, and has only a heater if needed, and two pumps - one small internal recirculation pump which is always on, and a slightly larger pump with tubing to reach the 55 above it - the second pump is only on when moving water to the 55 - it even has a remote switch so that I can turn it on and off while sitting or standing in front of the tank.
On change day, I use the Python to remove 1/2 the water column (1/2 the height of the open water above the substrate), with light surface vacuuming only (it is a planted tank). Then I pump water from the 33XL to the 55 up to the proper fill level - don't walk away while filling!. When the 55 is refiled, remove the connecting tubing from the 55 and leave it atop the 33XL with the delivery end down in the 33XL. Flush out the Python at the sink, then refill the 33XL, add Prime as needed, and the water will be ready for the next water change when needed. Store the Python, wipe the outside of the front glass, and the partial is complete.
Yes, it requires extra pumps and a tank, but it means that I always have water ready to use for water changes, and I do not have too carry anything other than the Python and the Prime bottle.and pipette. Changes themselves are faster and simpler and neater. To me it is a no-brainer. If you figure the time saved over the expected 10-year life of any on my set-ups, moving 20+gallons of water every week or at least 50 weeks a year time 10 years setup life, the extra tnk and pump are cheap. That is moving more than 1100 gallons a year to the tank, over a ten-year setup life, that is over 8000 pounds of water - if my math is right. No thank you. I simplify my life and make many fewer messes. My wife would raise cain if I lugged and sloshed water all over the the place routinely. First rule of fish-keeping: Keep the spouse happy, or at least accepting.
HTH