Page 2 of 3
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:09 am
by LilGreenPuffer
I wouldn't be willing to kill it (icky!), but I'll eat it myself! Shrimp, ummy!
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:19 am
by Lil' Swimz$
I mentioned I was feeding snails to my puffers and got shot at like crazy.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 4:07 pm
by marksrush
schismy007 wrote:I got put down really badly on another forum because I mentioned that I was breeding guppies to feed to my piscivore puffers. Not just one or two comments, but a long rambling paragraph after paragraph blasting of me for doing such a horrible thing!

1) Ask such people what they had for dinner last night. Chances are it involved some sort of meat. If so, they have no room to talk.
2) Tell them to take it up with God, the one who created carnivores and piscivores, along with herbivores.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 4:28 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I'm not bothered, I can sleep easily at night, and I know that what I'm doing isn't cruel.
The fish are eaten quickly, they aren't tortured and tormented. I never give my puffers fish bigger than they can eat in one go, that way it just about guarantees that the guppy will go in one smooth suck-in (they don't actually bite them, they suck them into their mouths).
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 5:16 pm
by marksrush
Exactly: you do what you have to do to provide for your live-eating pet, and you do it as mercifully as possible. I breed mice for my ball python, and while feeding him is not something that I enjoy having to do (I also have some favorite pet mice), it's just simply necessary. The mice die, usually, in less than a minute, and up until the time they're placed in the snake enclosure they live very well.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 7:10 pm
by Troender
The only living things I feed my puffers are snails. This is mostly because feeding with living food (at least fish, I don't know if it also means shrimps - snails are not illegal though) is not legal in Norway. I know many others do it, but I don't - well, not on purpose that is. I have an awful lot of bristlenose babies getting eaten all the time. But that's nothing I feed them - they only get eaten because they grow up in a veeery dangerous environment (my denisoni barbs love bristlenose babies!).
I actually have big trouble with killing anything. That's not because I think it's wrong. It's only because I am stupid that way. But I have absolutely no problems eating anything that has been alive at some time.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 7:21 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Troender wrote:
I actually have big trouble with killing anything. That's not because I think it's wrong. It's only because I am stupid that way. But I have absolutely no problems eating anything that has been alive at some time.
Yep, that's me! I was going to freeze a ghost shrimp so that I could feed it to my DPs a bit at a time. I just plain chickened out. I feed worms and live snails without a problem, but they don't have faces!
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 8:45 pm
by pufferfreak
I just throw the live food in there and watch them eat it. Its interesting watching them hunt down their "prey".
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 5:50 am
by pufferpuggirl
Well even though I breed guppies to feed to my piscivore puffers, if I had to kill anything to feed myself, I think I'd probably go hungry. No kidding. I'm a real wimp when it comes to things like that, and I grew up in a family where my father hunted alot and we ate everything he killed, it wasn't just for the sake of killing. Even so, I don't think I could kill a deer like my Dad used to. It didn't bother me as a kid, we'd go down and watch him dressing the deer, but we grew up with that, so it wasn't unusual. But now, well I think it's a horrible thing and I don't advocate hunting at all, unless it's absolutely done for the sake of feeding yourself.
So there, that's me on my soap box for today!

Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 10:24 am
by LilGreenPuffer
I really support hunting that is done ethically, not merely for sport. My cousin hunts, and he makes amazing sausage and steak and whatnot. I also know people (now vegans!) who used to use not only the meat, but the leather. Hunting is essential to population control, especially with deer, since humans are destroying their habitats. Deer are starving because there's too many animals in too little space. Plus, free-range, hormone-free meat is healthier for us and way better than factory farming.
I guess what I'm saying is, I have no objection to live feeding, hunting, and other practices deemed "cruel" by many. When you look at the issue, it's often a good thing.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 4:08 pm
by Lil' Swimz$
I live in an area where turkey are almost invasive. We used to have little to none around when my grandpa was little but now they're all over. They're outcompeting pheasants. My dad hunts them every year. Infact I'm taking hunter safety this fall. We have some beautiful white tails around too, just across the road. My parents hit a buck once in their truck just down the road at night. My dad doesn't hunt deer or bucks, he'd rather watch them. I'd never kill something for the sake of killing either. I go fishing with my dad and he LOVES bluegills and croppies. My, on the other hand, don't eat fish, I like them too much, and plus I think they taste nasty.
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 8:26 pm
by Bluntokian
now i cant go as far as the fish statement i used to farm catfish for salt n pepper cat...but however it IS life...people need to get over it its kill or be killed that simple and as far as im concerned if someone tried to kill me right now i would kill them and sleep just fine tonight knowing it was kill or be killed but i guess what im saying is yes as long as your entirely humane about it its fine if neccesary
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 9:57 pm
by Dadof4
Lil' Swimz$ wrote:I live in an area where turkey are almost invasive. We used to have little to none around when my grandpa was little but now they're all over. They're outcompeting pheasants. My dad hunts them every year. Infact I'm taking hunter safety this fall. We have some beautiful white tails around too, just across the road. My parents hit a buck once in their truck just down the road at night. My dad doesn't hunt deer or bucks, he'd rather watch them. I'd never kill something for the sake of killing either. I go fishing with my dad and he LOVES bluegills and croppies. My, on the other hand, don't eat fish, I like them too much, and plus I think they taste nasty.
Oh Dear Gawd! Lil' Swimz$ in the woods with a gun...and a loaded one too! I'm leaving the state when hunting starts again or buying Kevlar underwear!

Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 4:19 am
by diverchic
Re: Do People think You're Mean?
Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 4:43 am
by Corvus
I guess that's a question of perspective. I think some people might think I'm mean if I was feeding puffers to larger predators, too. So, I totally understand the people critizising puffer keepers for feeding shrimps, crabs, snails and so on.
Many lifeforms live from the death of another... nature's a mean mother.