Page 2 of 2

Re: I bought a sick puffer...

Posted: Sat May 16, 2009 12:31 pm
by Bogwoodbruce
A good point has been made, just because a store has a sick fish or one that just isnt right doesnt make it a bad store.I work in one and when we get a sick fish we always treat but somtimes it just isnt cost effective or possible to treat. Its a business aswell not just a hobby. Its somthing that has to be learnt. Although some cases are downto a basic lack of care :)

Just my opinion

Re: I bought a sick puffer...

Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 3:48 pm
by Jase
Bogwoodbruce wrote:I work in one and when we get a sick fish we always treat but somtimes it just isnt cost effective or possible to treat. Its a business aswell not just a hobby.
Sorry, but that to me is kinda like doctors selling expired medication because it's not cost effective to get new meds. It is not responsible and is unethical both in business and fishkeeping.
I'm pretty sure all the bad LFSs I've been to have been a business, not a hobby. Nobody gets rich owning a fish store. If you're going to own one, yes you want to make money, but I think you have to be into fish and sharing good knowledge more than anything.

Re: I bought a sick puffer...

Posted: Sun May 17, 2009 5:13 pm
by yunachin
I know this for a fact. I own a fish place and I never, ever, ever do not have the time to treat sick fish. If something cannot be treated, it dies and you take it as a loss. You don't stick it in a window tank and hope the next unsuspecting sucker comes by to get it off your hands. Running a successful fish business requires a good reputation with customers which can include spending the time to research certain requirements for fish, for example mbu puffers. I would never in my right mind order a fish like this and pop it in a 20 gallon so someone can buy it and take it home to put it in their 55 so it can "grow out". "Grow out" tanks are excuses in the fish business. Mind you that is my opinion but I find it hard to see that you can stick a fish in a small tank and hope that until you get your finances together that he won't be affected by stunting. I think it's selfish.

Yes, sick fish come in and it is the fish stores responsibility to see that that fish is quarantined and treated before it leaves the premises. Or like Woodbutcher said, have it sent to an experienced fish keeper willing to put forth the time, money and effort to cure the fish to be passed on to others. If you are in this business to make a quick buck then you are in the wrong business.