Page 2 of 2

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:38 pm
by Agnate
Just remember that ammonia and nitrite need to be completely untraceable (0 ppm), so keep checking the levels until you see this occur.

Also, the 7 gallon hex will not be worth the money. Also, hex tanks are generally bad for puffers, as they prefer swimming room on a horizontal axis, and really don't use height very much. There are fish that prefer height over width/depth (such as Discus), but they're few and far between.

I would honestly suggest looking for used tanks in your local newspaper and online classifieds (such as Kijiji). Used tanks are usually valued at almost half of the new price, which means you almost-always get a good deal. Generally you can pick up a 30 gallon with a stand, filter, heater, and lid for $100 (CAD) at the absolute most. As such, I'd avoid brand new tanks for now and try to find a well-priced used one. Look for tanks with glass lids (easier to clean), AquaClear filters (a good brand of hang-on-back filters) or canister filters (a good type of filter), and a 200-250 watt heater. That's not to say you'll find ALL of those in a used package, but if you have a few choices, look for those things.

If you need any help deciding, don't hesitate to ask us! We're always eager to help. :)

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:25 am
by Pufferpunk
Ummm... Ammonia <20? Test it again. Nothing could live long even around 5.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 10:02 pm
by drives2002bmw
I have added the bio-spira 2 days ago and been checking the ammonia amounts which are very very low. close to zero and have added a feeder danio to see if he will like that to chase and eat. He seems to be bored and just hanging around the bottom of the tank and hiding. he is not as active as when I first got him. Do puffers sometimes just relax and not swim around much? or could there be something wrong with him?
The ammonia tester i have has yellow as 0ppm and slight green as 20ppm. It is definitly not 20ppm and looks very close to the 0ppm. I might not be able to see the water color correctly and it might actually be at 0ppm.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:00 pm
by drives2002bmw
HE seems to be trying to wedge himself between a plant and the side of the tank. He got out and swam around for a bit and then went back into that spot. I just did a 70% water change and will do daily until the bio-spira starts to get the ammonia down to 0. The test i did showed zero but who knows.

Pictures:
Image
Image
Image

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:56 pm
by drives2002bmw
I think my puffer has checked out. He is not moving at the bottom of the tank. SUCKS!!!!!! I am really bummed.... I really do like puffers and will researching and getting another big tank to better accomidate my next puffer. Thanks for all your help and I will be back with more questions the next time I have a puffer.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:22 am
by Pufferpunk
I'm sorry to hear that. I'm afraid you might not have given the B-S a chance to work before you removed it with the large WC. It takes about 48 hours. Did you add it directly to the filter? Instead of offering your puffer a fish to eat, live worms would have been more appropriate. They can also easily be soaked in vitamins.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 9:36 am
by Agnate
By the looks of the picture, I think he also had a fungal infection, which probably didn't help your situation. :(

Sorry to hear that, though. Unfortunately, this situation has happened to about every person on this forum. :?

If you're still willing to give puffers a go, save up some cash and invest in a 30 gallon tank (the standard 30 gallons are pretty good shape, but you could also look into a 40/50 gallon breeder, which are fantastic tanks as well). You can learn about brackish tanks here, such as measuring the salt levels and whatnot. Then you can perform a fishless cycle on the tank, and you'll be ready to pick up your new GSP whenever a local store has one in good shape.

It's a shame, though, because other than the nipped fin and bit of fungus, your GSP looks like he was in pretty good shape (if only just a bit roughed up). :(

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:11 pm
by drives2002bmw
Are buying puffers from stores better or buying them from online? I have seen some sites that sell puffers. Would be this be ok or should I just ask my pet store guy (who I have grown to know well because of my almost daily visits to the store) to order one next time he gets a shipment.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:20 pm
by Pufferpunk
I always like to pick out my fish by eye when I can. Especially puffers, where you want the one who greets you at the front of the tank!

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:06 pm
by Agnate
Aye, I would have to agree. I much prefer seeing them in the store before I purchase them.

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 10:03 pm
by drives2002bmw
Good to know. Yea I picked this one out because the other two were not as vibrant in their colors and their stomachs were not as fat as the one I got. I am not looking on craigslist for anywhere from 30-100 gallon tanks for one. I can see why a puffer forum and begun. These little guys are addicting. I have my other tank with mollies and neons, but it just isn't the same as a puffer. I will most definitly be looking into getting another puffer once I get a established bigger tank. Are there easier puffers to take care of other than the GSP? perhaps a freshwater that is less susceptible to infections and water conditions?

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 10:39 pm
by marksrush
Question: isn't Bio-Spira only for marine environments now? I thought it was. So if this person put B-S in their freshwater tank, it would have been useless, right?

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:25 am
by Agnate
I was under the impression that there are different BioSpiras for different water types. BioSpira also isn't a 100% guarantee, as the LFS could be avoiding its refrigeration, or the bottle is passed its expiry date.

I honestly think it was more than an uncycled tank that ended him, but the uncycled conditions probably exacerbated his situation. Since GSPs should be in brackish (unless they're newborns), his immune system was probably affected greatly and undoubtedly hindered the entire situation. Combine all these together, and the fact that he seemed to have a fungal infection of sorts, and you've got yourself a lot of problems. :(

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 10:27 am
by edmlfc1
marksrush wrote:Question: isn't Bio-Spira only for marine environments now? I thought it was. So if this person put B-S in their freshwater tank, it would have been useless, right?
There are 3 brands:
Dr Tims (saltwater, freshwater & reef) - http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/p ... atid=18986

Tetra Safestart (freshwater): http://www.thatpetplace.com/pet/prod/24 ... rBZPiR3FoS

Instant ocean (saltwater): http://www.instantocean.com/sites/Insta ... plash.html

Re: NEED HELP with new 1.5" GSP New Puffer Owner

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 7:59 pm
by marksrush
Yes, edmlfc1, I know that but thanks for posting those convenient links - they make clear the fact that only the saltwater one is called BioSpira now. My point, actually (which I was trying to make in a roundabout way) was that this person got the advice to add BioSpira to their tank, yet it's a freshwater tank.